SOVIET POLITBURO Survivor - GORBACHEV is a survivor
       |           

Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.
Did you miss your activation email?
March 28, 2024, 05:05:35 AM
News: Election Simulator 2.0 Released. Senate/Gubernatorial maps, proportional electoral votes, and more - Read more

  Talk Elections
  Election Archive
  Election Archive
  Survivor
  SOVIET POLITBURO Survivor - GORBACHEV is a survivor
« previous next »
Pages: 1 [2] 3 4 5 6 7 ... 9
Author Topic: SOVIET POLITBURO Survivor - GORBACHEV is a survivor  (Read 79762 times)
Chancellor Tanterterg
Mr. X
Moderators
Atlas Star
*****
Posts: 26,201
United States


Show only this user's posts in this thread
« Reply #25 on: June 04, 2010, 09:30:55 AM »

Bolsheviks
2 KALININ
2 TROTSKIY
1 CHUBAR

Open Bolsheviks
2 SOKOLNIKOV
2 RADEK
1 FRUNZE

Stalinists
2 POSTYSHEV
2 KAGANOVICH
1 YAGODA

Open Stalinists
2 ORDZHONIKIDZE
2 VOZNESENSKIY
1 KUYBYSHEV

Brezhnevians
2 GRECHKO
2 TIKHONOV
1 KUZNETSOV

Modern conservatives
2 ROMANOV
2 KRYUCHKOV
1 KIRILENKO

Khrushchevians
2 KUUSINEN
2 KOZLOV
1 PODGORNIY
Logged
Hans-im-Glück
Franken
Junior Chimp
*****
Posts: 7,970
Germany


Political Matrix
E: -5.94, S: -3.30

Show only this user's posts in this thread
« Reply #26 on: June 04, 2010, 10:19:43 AM »

Bolsheviks
2   KALININ
2   CHUBAR
1   LENIN

Open Bolsheviks
2   FRUNZE
2   RADEK
1   SOKOLNIKOV

Stalinists
2   YAGODA
2   KAGANOVICH
1   ZHDANOV

Open Stalinists
2   ORDZHONIKIDZE
2   MALENKOV
1   VOZNESENSKIY

Brezhnevians
2   RASHIDOV
2   GROMYKO
1   TIKHONOV

Modern conservatives
2   ROMANOV
2   KRYUCHKOV
1   KIRILENKO

Khrushchevians
2   KUUSINEN
2   PODGORNIY
1   KOZLOV
Logged
Edu
Ufokart
Junior Chimp
*****
Posts: 7,864
Argentina


Show only this user's posts in this thread
« Reply #27 on: June 04, 2010, 11:34:56 AM »

Bolsheviks
2 for Mikhail Ivanovich KALININ
2 for Vlas CHUBAR
1 for Lev Bronstein TROTSKIY

Open Bolsheviks
2 for Mikhail FRUNZE
2 for Grigoriy Brilliant SOKOLNIKOV
1 for Karl RADEK

Stalinists
2 for Pavel POSTYSHEV
2 for Genrikh YAGODA
1 for Lazar KAGANOVICH

Open Stalinists
2 for Nikolay VOZNESENSKIY
2 for Dmitriy SHEPILOV
1 for Mikhail PERVUKHIN

Brezhnevians
2 for Sharaf RASHIDOV
2 for Nikolay TIKHONOV
1 for Vasiliy KUZNETSOV

Modern conservatives
2 for Vladimir KRYUCHKOV
2 for Andrey KIRILENKO
1 for Viktor CHEBRIKOV

Khrushchevians
2 for Aleksandr SHELEPIN
2 for Frol KOZLOV
1 for Otto KUUSINEN
Logged
big bad fab
filliatre
Atlas Icon
*****
Posts: 13,344
Ukraine


Show only this user's posts in this thread
« Reply #28 on: June 07, 2010, 03:19:55 AM »

Including the round I'm opening now, there will be 6 rounds in which we'll eliminate 7, then 4, then 3 Politburo members. And so, we'll still use the 7 groups.
After that, we'll have only one big group and we'll purge the Politburo members one by one, but still with sophisticated rules (Wink): I know you love them... and the turnout is too low to stick to usual rules (Sad).


"Bolsheviks":
Vladimir Ulyanov LENIN (1917-1924)
Lev Bronstein TROTSKIY (1917-1926)
Mikhail Ivanovich KALININ (1919-1946)
Yakov SVERDLOV (1918-1919)
Yelena STASOVA (1917-1918, 1919)
Yevgeniy PREOBRAZHENSKIY (1917-1918, 1920-1921)
Yan RUDZUTAK (1926-1932, 1934-1938)
Stanislav KOSIOR (1927-1939)
Vlas CHUBAR (1926-1938)


"Open bolsheviks":
Lev Rozenfeld KAMENEV (1917-1926)
Grigoriy Radomyslskiy ZINOVYEV (1917-1926)
Nikolay BUKHARIN (1917-1929)
Aleksey RYKOV (1922-1930)
Mikhail TOMSKIY (1922-1930)
Nikolay KRESTINSKIY (1917-1921)
Mikhail FRUNZE (1924-1925)
Grigoriy Brilliant SOKOLNIKOV (1917-1919)
Karl RADEK (-)
Mikhail TUKHACHEVSKIY (-)


"Stalinists":
Iosif Dzhugashvili STALIN (1917-1953)
Vyacheslav Skryabin MOLOTOV (1921-1957)
Kliment VOROSHILOV (1926-1960)
Lazar KAGANOVICH (1926-1957)
Feliks DZERZHINSKIY (1918-1919, 1924-1926)
Andrey ZHDANOV (1935-1948)
Nikolay YEZHOV (1937-1938)
Andrey ANDREYEV (1926-1930, 1932-1952)
Lavrentiy BERIYA (1939-1953)
Andrey VYSHINSKIY (1952-1953)
Pavel POSTYSHEV (1934-1938)
Genrikh YAGODA (-)


"Open stalinists":
Georgiy MALENKOV (1941-1957)
Nikolay BULGANIN (1946-1958)
Anastas MIKOYAN (1926-1966)
Dmitriy SHEPILOV (1956-1957)
Sergey Kostrikov KIROV (1926-1934)
Maksim SABUROV (1952-1957)
Mikhail PERVUKHIN (1952-1961)
Nikolay VOZNESENSKIY (1941-1949)
Georgiy ZHUKOV (1956-1957)
Grigori Sergo ORDZHONIKIDZE (1930-1937)
Valerian KUYBYSHEV (1927-1935)


"Brezhnevians":
Leonid BREZHNEV (1952-1953, 1957-1982)
Konstantin CHERNENKO (1977-1985)
Nikolay TIKHONOV (1978-1985)
Andrey GROMYKO (1973-1988)
Vasiliy KUZNETSOV (1952-1953, 1977-1986)
Mikhail SUSLOV (1952-1953, 1955-1982)
Dmitriy USTINOV (1965-1984)
Andrey GRECHKO (1973-1976)
Vladimir SHCHERBITSKIY (1961-1963, 1965-1989)
Viktor GRISHIN (1961-1986)
Sharaf RASHIDOV (1961-1983)
Boris PONOMAREV (1972-1986)


"Modern conservatives":
Aleksey KOSYGIN (1946-1953, 1957-1980)
Andrey KIRILENKO (1957-1961, 1962-1982)
Grigoriy ROMANOV (1973-1985)
Nikolay RYZHKOV (1985-1990)
Gennadiy YANAYEV (1990-1991)
Anatoliy LUKYANOV (1988-1990)
Yegor LIGACHEV (1985-1990)
Lev ZAYKOV (1986-1990)
Viktor CHEBRIKOV (1983-1989)
Vladimir KRYUCHKOV (1989-1990)
Heidar ALIYEV (1976-1987)
Pyotr SHELEST (1963-1973)
Valentin PAVLOV (-)


"Khrushchevians":
Nikita Sergeyevich KHRUSHCHEV (1938-1964)
Yuriy ANDROPOV (1967-1984)
Nikolay PODGORNIY (1958-1977)
Nikolay SHVERNIK (1939-1966)
Aleksandr SHELEPIN (1964-1975)
Frol KOZLOV (1956-1964)
Fyodor KULAKOV (1971-1978)
Dmitriy POLYANSKIY (1958-1976)
Otto KUUSINEN (1952-1953, 1957-1964)
Mikhail GORBACHEV (1979-1991)
Aleksandr YAKOVLEV (1987-1990)
Eduard SHEVARDNADZE (1978-1990)
Boris YELTSIN (1986-1988)

Results:

Round 1:
Kosior 1.67, Lenin 1.33, Trotskiy 1.33, Kalinin 0.67, Sverdlov 0.67, Chubar 0.33
Krestinskiy 1.33 (+ GenSek's decision), Frunze 1.33, Zinovyev 1.33, Kamenev 0.67, Rykov 0.67, Bukharin 0.33, Sokolnikov 1
Stalin 3.33, Yezhov 1, Postyshev 0.67, Beriya 0.33, Kaganovich 0.33, Yagoda 0.33
Zhukov 1.67 (+ GenSek's decision), Mikoyan 1.67, Bulganin 1, Malenkov 0.67, Kuybyshev 0.33, Ordzhonikidze 0.33, Shepilov 0.33
Chernenko 2.67, Brezhnev 1.33, Gromylo 0.67, Shcherbitskiy 0.67, Rashidov 0.33, Suslov 0.33
Yanayev 1.33 (+ GenSek's decision), Aliyev 1.33, Kirilenko 1.33, Kosygin 1.33, Pavlov 0.67, Ryzhkov 0.33
Shvernik 2.67, Polyanskiy 1.67, Khrushchev 0.67, Yeltsin 0.67, Andropov 0.33

Round 2:
Stasova 1.5, Kalinin 1, Troskiy 0.5, Sverdlov 0.5 (-1), Lenin 0.5 (-3)
Zinovyev 1.5, Frunze 1 (-1), Kamenev 1 (-1), Sokolnikov 0.5, Radek 0 (-1)
Yezhov 1.5, Postyshev 1, Beriya 1 (-1), Yagoda 0.5 (-1), Dzerzhinskiy 0 (-1), Zhdanov 0 (-1)
Saburov 1.5 (-1 + GenSek's decision), Mikoyan 1.5 (-1), Kuybyshev 0.5, Voznesenskiy 0.5, Kirov 0 (-1), Ordzhonikidze 0 (-1)
Shcherbitskiy 1 (0), Rashidov 1 (-1), Grechko 0.5, Gromyko 0.5, Brezhnev 0.5 (-1), Tikhonov 0.5 (-1), Suslov 0 (-1)
Aliyev 1.5 (-1 + GenSek's decision), Kirilenko 1.5 (-1), Pavlov 1 (-2)
Polyanskiy 2, Khrushchev 1 (-1), Kuusinen 0.5, Shelepin 0.5, Yakovlev 0 (-1), Andropov 0 (-2)

Round 3:
Sverdlov 3, Kalinin 1, Lenin 1
Kamenev 3, Frunze 2
Beriya 1, Kaganovich 1, Postyshev 1, Yagoda 1
Mikoyan 3, Shepilov, Voznesensky 1
Brezhnev 2 (1.83 previous vote), Rashidov 2 (1.33 previous vote), Gromyko 1
Pavlov 3, Kirilenko 2
Khrushchev 2, Gorbachev 1, Kuusinen 1, Shelepin 1

Round 4:
Kalinin 1.6, Chubar 1, Trotskiy 0.8, Lenin 0.6
Frunze 1.4 (4.33 previous votes), Sokolnikov 1.4 (1.5 previous votes), Radek 1, Tukhachevskiy 0.2
Yagoda 1.4, Kaganovich 1.2, Postyshev 0.8, Vyshinskiy 0.4, Zhdanov 0.2
Voznesesnkiy 1.2, Ordzhonikidze 0.8, Shepilov 0.8, Pervukhin 0.6, Malenkov 0.4, Kuybyshev 0.2
Tikhonov 1.4, Rashidov 1.2, Kuznetsov 0.6, Grechko 0.4, Gromyko 0.4
Kryuchkov 1.6, Kirilenko 0.8, Romanov 0.8, Chebrikov 0.6, Kosygin 0.2
Kuusinen 1.4, Kozlov 1.2, Podgroniy 1, Shelepin 0.4

Rules are different in each round: please read the rules before voting.
The Politburo member who receives the biggest total of votes or points is purged.
In case of a tie, the Politburo member who has received the biggest total of previous votes is purged.
In case of a new tie, I, GenSek of this survivor, decide who is purged.

ROUND 5 IS OPEN !

Beware !In this round, you have a TOTAL of 7 votes, that you must spread in at least 4 groups, with votes for only one Politburo member in each group and with a maximum of 3 votes for the same Politburo member.
So, you can cast your votes among the 7 groups as follows:
3-2-1-1 / 3-1-1-1 / 2-2-2-1 / 2-2-1-1-1 / 2-1-1-1-1-1 / 1-1-1-1-1-1-1
We'll purge 1 Politburo member in EACH group.

Beware !
Logged
big bad fab
filliatre
Atlas Icon
*****
Posts: 13,344
Ukraine


Show only this user's posts in this thread
« Reply #29 on: June 07, 2010, 03:30:45 AM »
« Edited: June 07, 2010, 04:22:17 PM by big bad fab »

Bolsheviks:
Lenin 2
(trying a small Blitzkrieg Wink)

Open bolsheviks:
no vote
(because I don't really care for anyone here, except maybe Rykov)

Stalinists:
no vote
(well, now that Beriya is out, I don't really care, even though I'd like to see Vyshinskiy, Kaganovich and Andreyev out soon)

Open stalinists:
Shepilov 1
(I must protect "Sergo", you know... it's a bit stupid as I'm trying to kill a funny if short-lived coup-monger Tongue)

Brezhnevians:
no vote
(Suslov and Ponomarev aren't threatened and, with luck, Rashidov will be ousted without my help... of course, we may lose Grechko... but this round is full of forced choices !)

Modern conservatives:
Chebrikov 2
(Kirilenko and now Romanov threatened... my favourite bad guys in this group -if you consider Andropov and Lukyanov as "good" guys !-... I must act !)

Khrushchevians:
Kozlov 2
(maybe it's a mistake to give 2 points here, but Shelepin deserves my protection Wink)

EDIT: typos
Logged
Hans-im-Glück
Franken
Junior Chimp
*****
Posts: 7,970
Germany


Political Matrix
E: -5.94, S: -3.30

Show only this user's posts in this thread
« Reply #30 on: June 07, 2010, 09:58:43 AM »

Bolsheviks:
No Vote

Open bolsheviks:
No Vote

Stalinists:
2   DZERZHINSKIY

Open stalinists:
1   MALENKOV

Brezhnevians:
No Vote

Modern conservatives:
2   ROMANOV

Khrushchevians:
2   SHELEPIN
Logged
Chancellor Tanterterg
Mr. X
Moderators
Atlas Star
*****
Posts: 26,201
United States


Show only this user's posts in this thread
« Reply #31 on: June 07, 2010, 11:01:17 AM »
« Edited: June 07, 2010, 11:06:33 AM by Mr. X »

Bolsheviks
1 TROTSKIY (I'm less concerned about the outcome in this catagory, but it seems too early for Lenin to be elimenated)

Open Bolsheviks
No Vote  

Stalinists
3 POSTYSHEV (Got to protect Dzerzhinskiy! He makes things so much more interesting Wink )

Open Stalinists
No Vote

Brezhnevians
2 GRECHKO (I find the idea of an Uzbek making it far in a Soviet Polituro survivor quite amusing)

Modern conservatives
1 ROMANOV (Hopefully this is all it will take to elimenate him)

Khrushchevians
No vote
Logged
Edu
Ufokart
Junior Chimp
*****
Posts: 7,864
Argentina


Show only this user's posts in this thread
« Reply #32 on: June 07, 2010, 08:55:23 PM »

Bolsheviks
2 for Lev Bronstein TROTSKIY

Open bolsheviks
1 for Grigoriy Brilliant SOKOLNIKOV

Brezhnevians
2 for Sharaf RASHIDOV

Modern conservatives
2 for Viktor CHEBRIKOV

No votes in Stalinists, Open Stalinists and Khrushchevians
Logged
big bad fab
filliatre
Atlas Icon
*****
Posts: 13,344
Ukraine


Show only this user's posts in this thread
« Reply #33 on: June 08, 2010, 05:13:00 AM »

My second big "loss", after Beriya: Shelepin... It would have been so fascinating had his attempt to seize power succeeded... Wink A, man of so many "what-ifs". In relations with the Soviet block, he would have probably been more moderate than the so-called moderate Brezhnev, Kosygin and even Podgorniy. And he may have been able to reform the economy a bit more efficiently than Kosygin.
Of course, you may argue his image was overvalued, like all the other "potential" reformers from the KGB (Beriya, Andropov), who may have been able to intoxicate foreigners and to have "friends" contributing to build a positive if fake image.

I'm a bit sad Trotskiy is out before Lenin, who was less complex and more opportunistic. But the rules weren't easy to use efficiently ! Wink
Edu was good at them (being the last to vote is of course easier, in a way): he has ousted Sokolnikov with just one vote.
This round may provide other examples...

Romanov, a corrupt and erratic guy, but so fascinating, is safe and I'm happy. Under Andropov, he had a short "golden period", talked of as a potential Nr.1. The fight between Romanov and Gorbachev, the latter using some of the old Brezhnevians (especially Gromyko) and Romanov depending on so-called reformists (who were just "modern conservatives") like Vorotnikov and Solomentsev, was very interesting.

Postyshev was another "pittoresque" guy, like Kirov, "Sergo",... Many of them in the 1930s, but also in the 1950s (Zhukov, Shepilov, Mr. K himself).
But, well, Postyshev wasn't an angel, even though he was close to Kirov...

Rashidov is out, sorry jdb, but this corrupt and nasty guy was a good resume for the last years of brezhnevism.


"Bolsheviks":
Vladimir Ulyanov LENIN (1917-1924)
Lev Bronstein TROTSKIY (1917-1926)
Mikhail Ivanovich KALININ (1919-1946)
Yakov SVERDLOV (1918-1919)
Yelena STASOVA (1917-1918, 1919)
Yevgeniy PREOBRAZHENSKIY (1917-1918, 1920-1921)
Yan RUDZUTAK (1926-1932, 1934-1938)
Stanislav KOSIOR (1927-1939)
Vlas CHUBAR (1926-1938)


"Open bolsheviks":
Lev Rozenfeld KAMENEV (1917-1926)
Grigoriy Radomyslskiy ZINOVYEV (1917-1926)
Nikolay BUKHARIN (1917-1929)
Aleksey RYKOV (1922-1930)
Mikhail TOMSKIY (1922-1930)
Nikolay KRESTINSKIY (1917-1921)
Mikhail FRUNZE (1924-1925)
Grigoriy Brilliant SOKOLNIKOV (1917-1919)
Karl RADEK (-)
Mikhail TUKHACHEVSKIY (-)


"Stalinists":
Iosif Dzhugashvili STALIN (1917-1953)
Vyacheslav Skryabin MOLOTOV (1921-1957)
Kliment VOROSHILOV (1926-1960)
Lazar KAGANOVICH (1926-1957)
Feliks DZERZHINSKIY (1918-1919, 1924-1926)
Andrey ZHDANOV (1935-1948)
Nikolay YEZHOV (1937-1938)
Andrey ANDREYEV (1926-1930, 1932-1952)
Lavrentiy BERIYA (1939-1953)
Andrey VYSHINSKIY (1952-1953)
Pavel POSTYSHEV (1934-1938)
Genrikh YAGODA (-)


"Open stalinists":
Georgiy MALENKOV (1941-1957)
Nikolay BULGANIN (1946-1958)
Anastas MIKOYAN (1926-1966)
Dmitriy SHEPILOV (1956-1957)
Sergey Kostrikov KIROV (1926-1934)
Maksim SABUROV (1952-1957)
Mikhail PERVUKHIN (1952-1961)
Nikolay VOZNESENSKIY (1941-1949)
Georgiy ZHUKOV (1956-1957)
Grigori Sergo ORDZHONIKIDZE (1930-1937)
Valerian KUYBYSHEV (1927-1935)


"Brezhnevians":
Leonid BREZHNEV (1952-1953, 1957-1982)
Konstantin CHERNENKO (1977-1985)
Nikolay TIKHONOV (1978-1985)
Andrey GROMYKO (1973-1988)
Vasiliy KUZNETSOV (1952-1953, 1977-1986)
Mikhail SUSLOV (1952-1953, 1955-1982)
Dmitriy USTINOV (1965-1984)
Andrey GRECHKO (1973-1976)
Vladimir SHCHERBITSKIY (1961-1963, 1965-1989)
Viktor GRISHIN (1961-1986)
Sharaf RASHIDOV (1961-1983)
Boris PONOMAREV (1972-1986)


"Modern conservatives":
Aleksey KOSYGIN (1946-1953, 1957-1980)
Andrey KIRILENKO (1957-1961, 1962-1982)
Grigoriy ROMANOV (1973-1985)
Nikolay RYZHKOV (1985-1990)
Gennadiy YANAYEV (1990-1991)
Anatoliy LUKYANOV (1988-1990)
Yegor LIGACHEV (1985-1990)
Lev ZAYKOV (1986-1990)
Viktor CHEBRIKOV (1983-1989)
Vladimir KRYUCHKOV (1989-1990)
Heidar ALIYEV (1976-1987)
Pyotr SHELEST (1963-1973)
Valentin PAVLOV (-)


"Khrushchevians":
Nikita Sergeyevich KHRUSHCHEV (1938-1964)
Yuriy ANDROPOV (1967-1984)
Nikolay PODGORNIY (1958-1977)
Nikolay SHVERNIK (1939-1966)
Aleksandr SHELEPIN (1964-1975)
Frol KOZLOV (1956-1964)
Fyodor KULAKOV (1971-1978)
Dmitriy POLYANSKIY (1958-1976)
Otto KUUSINEN (1952-1953, 1957-1964)
Mikhail GORBACHEV (1979-1991)
Aleksandr YAKOVLEV (1987-1990)
Eduard SHEVARDNADZE (1978-1990)
Boris YELTSIN (1986-1988)

Results:

Round 1:
Kosior 1.67, Lenin 1.33, Trotskiy 1.33, Kalinin 0.67, Sverdlov 0.67, Chubar 0.33
Krestinskiy 1.33 (+ GenSek's decision), Frunze 1.33, Zinovyev 1.33, Kamenev 0.67, Rykov 0.67, Bukharin 0.33, Sokolnikov 1
Stalin 3.33, Yezhov 1, Postyshev 0.67, Beriya 0.33, Kaganovich 0.33, Yagoda 0.33
Zhukov 1.67 (+ GenSek's decision), Mikoyan 1.67, Bulganin 1, Malenkov 0.67, Kuybyshev 0.33, Ordzhonikidze 0.33, Shepilov 0.33
Chernenko 2.67, Brezhnev 1.33, Gromyko 0.67, Shcherbitskiy 0.67, Rashidov 0.33, Suslov 0.33
Yanayev 1.33 (+ GenSek's decision), Aliyev 1.33, Kirilenko 1.33, Kosygin 1.33, Pavlov 0.67, Ryzhkov 0.33
Shvernik 2.67, Polyanskiy 1.67, Khrushchev 0.67, Yeltsin 0.67, Andropov 0.33

Round 2:
Stasova 1.5, Kalinin 1, Troskiy 0.5, Sverdlov 0.5 (-1), Lenin 0.5 (-3)
Zinovyev 1.5, Frunze 1 (-1), Kamenev 1 (-1), Sokolnikov 0.5, Radek 0 (-1)
Yezhov 1.5, Postyshev 1, Beriya 1 (-1), Yagoda 0.5 (-1), Dzerzhinskiy 0 (-1), Zhdanov 0 (-1)
Saburov 1.5 (-1 + GenSek's decision), Mikoyan 1.5 (-1), Kuybyshev 0.5, Voznesenskiy 0.5, Kirov 0 (-1), Ordzhonikidze 0 (-1)
Shcherbitskiy 1 (0), Rashidov 1 (-1), Grechko 0.5, Gromyko 0.5, Brezhnev 0.5 (-1), Tikhonov 0.5 (-1), Suslov 0 (-1)
Aliyev 1.5 (-1 + GenSek's decision), Kirilenko 1.5 (-1), Pavlov 1 (-2)
Polyanskiy 2, Khrushchev 1 (-1), Kuusinen 0.5, Shelepin 0.5, Yakovlev 0 (-1), Andropov 0 (-2)

Round 3:
Sverdlov 3, Kalinin 1, Lenin 1
Kamenev 3, Frunze 2
Beriya 1, Kaganovich 1, Postyshev 1, Yagoda 1
Mikoyan 3, Shepilov 1, Voznesensky 1
Brezhnev 2 (1.83 previous vote), Rashidov 2 (1.33 previous vote), Gromyko 1
Pavlov 3, Kirilenko 2
Khrushchev 2, Gorbachev 1, Kuusinen 1, Shelepin 1

Round 4:
Kalinin 1.6, Chubar 1, Trotskiy 0.8, Lenin 0.6
Frunze 1.4 (4.33 previous votes), Sokolnikov 1.4 (1.5 previous votes), Radek 1, Tukhachevskiy 0.2
Yagoda 1.4, Kaganovich 1.2, Postyshev 0.8, Vyshinskiy 0.4, Zhdanov 0.2
Voznesesnkiy 1.2, Ordzhonikidze 0.8, Shepilov 0.8, Pervukhin 0.6, Malenkov 0.4, Kuybyshev 0.2
Tikhonov 1.4, Rashidov 1.2, Kuznetsov 0.6, Grechko 0.4, Gromyko 0.4
Kryuchkov 1.6, Kirilenko 0.8, Romanov 0.8, Chebrikov 0.6, Kosygin 0.2
Kuusinen 1.4, Kozlov 1.2, Podgorniy 1, Shelepin 0.4

Round 5:
Trotskiy 3, Lenin 2
Sokolnikov 1
Postyshev 3, Dzerzhinskiy 2
Shepilov 1 (2.13 previous votes), Malenkov 1 (1.07 previous vote)
Rashidov 2 (4.53 previous votes), Grechko 2 (0.9 previous vote)
Chebrikov 4, Romanov 3
Shelepin 2 (1.9 previous vote), Kozlov 2 (1.2 previous vote)

Rules are different in each round: please read the rules before voting.
The Politburo member who receives the biggest total of votes or points is purged.
In case of a tie, the Politburo member who has received the biggest total of previous votes is purged.
In case of a new tie, I, GenSek of this survivor, decide who is purged.

ROUND 6 IS OPEN !

Beware !In this round, you have a TOTAL of 7 votes, that you must cast 2-2-1-1-1 in 5 different groups.
We'll purge 1 Politburo member in EACH group.

Beware !
Logged
big bad fab
filliatre
Atlas Icon
*****
Posts: 13,344
Ukraine


Show only this user's posts in this thread
« Reply #34 on: June 08, 2010, 05:27:37 AM »

Bolsheviks:
Lenin 2
(piling on...)

Open bolsheviks:
no vote
(I don't care...)

Stalinists:
Vyshinskiy 1
(mediocre evil)

Open stalinists:
Pervukhin 1
(uninteresting servant)

Brezhnevians:
Kuznetsov 1
(dull and grey)

Modern conservatives:
Zaykov 2
(less interesting and more conservative than anticipated, maybe even more than Ligachev)

Khrushchevians:
no vote
(I think none of my remaining favourites is threatened)
Logged
Hans-im-Glück
Franken
Junior Chimp
*****
Posts: 7,970
Germany


Political Matrix
E: -5.94, S: -3.30

Show only this user's posts in this thread
« Reply #35 on: June 08, 2010, 09:21:56 AM »

Bolsheviks:
No Vote

Open bolsheviks:
1   RYKOV

Stalinists:
2   DZERZHINSKIY

Open stalinists:
No Vote

Brezhnevians:
1  GROMYKO

Modern conservatives:
2 ROMANOV

Khrushchevians:
1 PODGORNIY
Logged
Chancellor Tanterterg
Mr. X
Moderators
Atlas Star
*****
Posts: 26,201
United States


Show only this user's posts in this thread
« Reply #36 on: June 08, 2010, 09:59:36 AM »

Bolsheviks
No Vote (Lenin shouldn't go yet, but I have higher priorities at the moment)

Open Bolsheviks
1 BUKHARIN (It worked for Edu...)

Stalinists
2 VYSHINSKIY (Got to protect Dzerzhinskiy!)

Open Stalinists
MALENKOV (why not?)

Brezhnevians
1 GRECHKO (boring, ineffective)

Modern conservatives
2 ROMANOV (He must go!)

Khrushchevians
(No vote, for the same reason as Fab)
Logged
Edu
Ufokart
Junior Chimp
*****
Posts: 7,864
Argentina


Show only this user's posts in this thread
« Reply #37 on: June 09, 2010, 12:20:56 AM »

Open Bolsheviks
2 for Karl RADEK

Open Stalinists
1 for Mikhail PERVUKHIN

Brezhnevians
1 for Vasiliy KUZNETSOV

Modern conservatives
1 for Andrey KIRILENKO (since i can't save Romanov because of past votes i will add to the vote count of this guy Tongue)

Khrushchevians
2 for Frol KOZLOV

No votes in Bolsheviks (even if i try to save Lenin he will still be ousted Sad) and Stalinists (i'm fine with Vyshinskiy going out)
Logged
big bad fab
filliatre
Atlas Icon
*****
Posts: 13,344
Ukraine


Show only this user's posts in this thread
« Reply #38 on: June 09, 2010, 04:51:17 AM »

With a good news (Lenin) came a bad news (Romanov): of course, it would be the other way round for some of you Tongue.

When you see that the fight was between Vyshinskiy and Dzerzhinskiy, well, it's really a "bad guys" survivor !
Edu didn't manage to keep Lenin, but killed Radek and Kozlov. Hans and jdb votes neutralized each other in the Brezhnevian and open Bolsheviks groups.

Anyway, sooner or later (and maybe rather sooner than later), Gromyko, Grechko, Dzerzhinskiy, Malenkov will all fall, as their count is higher and higher and as it's now difficult to "legitimately" protect them (the same is right for Kirilenko, BTW Grin).

Kuznetsov is purged: what is amazing in him is that, before being a paragon of "jurassic" brezhnevism in 1977-1986, he was a "young Turk" of open stalinism and then khrushchevism in the 1950s...
So many of these guys should be put in a big "remorseless opportunists"... (which is precisely what made them dangerous, as nothing counted apart from their own interest inside a dictatorship)


"Bolsheviks":
Vladimir Ulyanov LENIN (1917-1924)
Lev Bronstein TROTSKIY (1917-1926)
Mikhail Ivanovich KALININ (1919-1946)
Yakov SVERDLOV (1918-1919)
Yelena STASOVA (1917-1918, 1919)
Yevgeniy PREOBRAZHENSKIY (1917-1918, 1920-1921)
Yan RUDZUTAK (1926-1932, 1934-1938)
Stanislav KOSIOR (1927-1939)
Vlas CHUBAR (1926-1938)


"Open bolsheviks":
Lev Rozenfeld KAMENEV (1917-1926)
Grigoriy Radomyslskiy ZINOVYEV (1917-1926)
Nikolay BUKHARIN (1917-1929)
Aleksey RYKOV (1922-1930)
Mikhail TOMSKIY (1922-1930)
Nikolay KRESTINSKIY (1917-1921)
Mikhail FRUNZE (1924-1925)
Grigoriy Brilliant SOKOLNIKOV (1917-1919)
Karl RADEK (-)
Mikhail TUKHACHEVSKIY (-)


"Stalinists":
Iosif Dzhugashvili STALIN (1917-1953)
Vyacheslav Skryabin MOLOTOV (1921-1957)
Kliment VOROSHILOV (1926-1960)
Lazar KAGANOVICH (1926-1957)
Feliks DZERZHINSKIY (1918-1919, 1924-1926)
Andrey ZHDANOV (1935-1948)
Nikolay YEZHOV (1937-1938)
Andrey ANDREYEV (1926-1930, 1932-1952)
Lavrentiy BERIYA (1939-1953)
Andrey VYSHINSKIY (1952-1953)
Pavel POSTYSHEV (1934-1938)
Genrikh YAGODA (-)


"Open stalinists":
Georgiy MALENKOV (1941-1957)
Nikolay BULGANIN (1946-1958)
Anastas MIKOYAN (1926-1966)
Dmitriy SHEPILOV (1956-1957)
Sergey Kostrikov KIROV (1926-1934)
Maksim SABUROV (1952-1957)
Mikhail PERVUKHIN (1952-1961)
Nikolay VOZNESENSKIY (1941-1949)
Georgiy ZHUKOV (1956-1957)
Grigori Sergo ORDZHONIKIDZE (1930-1937)
Valerian KUYBYSHEV (1927-1935)


"Brezhnevians":
Leonid BREZHNEV (1952-1953, 1957-1982)
Konstantin CHERNENKO (1977-1985)
Nikolay TIKHONOV (1978-1985)
Andrey GROMYKO (1973-1988)
Vasiliy KUZNETSOV (1952-1953, 1977-1986)
Mikhail SUSLOV (1952-1953, 1955-1982)
Dmitriy USTINOV (1965-1984)
Andrey GRECHKO (1973-1976)
Vladimir SHCHERBITSKIY (1961-1963, 1965-1989)
Viktor GRISHIN (1961-1986)
Sharaf RASHIDOV (1961-1983)
Boris PONOMAREV (1972-1986)


"Modern conservatives":
Aleksey KOSYGIN (1946-1953, 1957-1980)
Andrey KIRILENKO (1957-1961, 1962-1982)
Grigoriy ROMANOV (1973-1985)
Nikolay RYZHKOV (1985-1990)
Gennadiy YANAYEV (1990-1991)
Anatoliy LUKYANOV (1988-1990)
Yegor LIGACHEV (1985-1990)
Lev ZAYKOV (1986-1990)
Viktor CHEBRIKOV (1983-1989)
Vladimir KRYUCHKOV (1989-1990)
Heidar ALIYEV (1976-1987)
Pyotr SHELEST (1963-1973)
Valentin PAVLOV (-)


"Khrushchevians":
Nikita Sergeyevich KHRUSHCHEV (1938-1964)
Yuriy ANDROPOV (1967-1984)
Nikolay PODGORNIY (1958-1977)
Nikolay SHVERNIK (1939-1966)
Aleksandr SHELEPIN (1964-1975)
Frol KOZLOV (1956-1964)
Fyodor KULAKOV (1971-1978)
Dmitriy POLYANSKIY (1958-1976)
Otto KUUSINEN (1952-1953, 1957-1964)
Mikhail GORBACHEV (1979-1991)
Aleksandr YAKOVLEV (1987-1990)
Eduard SHEVARDNADZE (1978-1990)
Boris YELTSIN (1986-1988)

Results:

Round 1:
Kosior 1.67, Lenin 1.33, Trotskiy 1.33, Kalinin 0.67, Sverdlov 0.67, Chubar 0.33
Krestinskiy 1.33 (+ GenSek's decision), Frunze 1.33, Zinovyev 1.33, Kamenev 0.67, Rykov 0.67, Bukharin 0.33, Sokolnikov 1
Stalin 3.33, Yezhov 1, Postyshev 0.67, Beriya 0.33, Kaganovich 0.33, Yagoda 0.33
Zhukov 1.67 (+ GenSek's decision), Mikoyan 1.67, Bulganin 1, Malenkov 0.67, Kuybyshev 0.33, Ordzhonikidze 0.33, Shepilov 0.33
Chernenko 2.67, Brezhnev 1.33, Gromyko 0.67, Shcherbitskiy 0.67, Rashidov 0.33, Suslov 0.33
Yanayev 1.33 (+ GenSek's decision), Aliyev 1.33, Kirilenko 1.33, Kosygin 1.33, Pavlov 0.67, Ryzhkov 0.33
Shvernik 2.67, Polyanskiy 1.67, Khrushchev 0.67, Yeltsin 0.67, Andropov 0.33

Round 2:
Stasova 1.5, Kalinin 1, Troskiy 0.5, Sverdlov 0.5 (-1), Lenin 0.5 (-3)
Zinovyev 1.5, Frunze 1 (-1), Kamenev 1 (-1), Sokolnikov 0.5, Radek 0 (-1)
Yezhov 1.5, Postyshev 1, Beriya 1 (-1), Yagoda 0.5 (-1), Dzerzhinskiy 0 (-1), Zhdanov 0 (-1)
Saburov 1.5 (-1 + GenSek's decision), Mikoyan 1.5 (-1), Kuybyshev 0.5, Voznesenskiy 0.5, Kirov 0 (-1), Ordzhonikidze 0 (-1)
Shcherbitskiy 1 (0), Rashidov 1 (-1), Grechko 0.5, Gromyko 0.5, Brezhnev 0.5 (-1), Tikhonov 0.5 (-1), Suslov 0 (-1)
Aliyev 1.5 (-1 + GenSek's decision), Kirilenko 1.5 (-1), Pavlov 1 (-2)
Polyanskiy 2, Khrushchev 1 (-1), Kuusinen 0.5, Shelepin 0.5, Yakovlev 0 (-1), Andropov 0 (-2)

Round 3:
Sverdlov 3, Kalinin 1, Lenin 1
Kamenev 3, Frunze 2
Beriya 1, Kaganovich 1, Postyshev 1, Yagoda 1
Mikoyan 3, Shepilov 1, Voznesensky 1
Brezhnev 2 (1.83 previous vote), Rashidov 2 (1.33 previous vote), Gromyko 1
Pavlov 3, Kirilenko 2
Khrushchev 2, Gorbachev 1, Kuusinen 1, Shelepin 1

Round 4:
Kalinin 1.6, Chubar 1, Trotskiy 0.8, Lenin 0.6
Frunze 1.4 (4.33 previous votes), Sokolnikov 1.4 (1.5 previous votes), Radek 1, Tukhachevskiy 0.2
Yagoda 1.4, Kaganovich 1.2, Postyshev 0.8, Vyshinskiy 0.4, Zhdanov 0.2
Voznesesnkiy 1.2, Ordzhonikidze 0.8, Shepilov 0.8, Pervukhin 0.6, Malenkov 0.4, Kuybyshev 0.2
Tikhonov 1.4, Rashidov 1.2, Kuznetsov 0.6, Grechko 0.4, Gromyko 0.4
Kryuchkov 1.6, Kirilenko 0.8, Romanov 0.8, Chebrikov 0.6, Kosygin 0.2
Kuusinen 1.4, Kozlov 1.2, Podgorniy 1, Shelepin 0.4

Round 5:
Trotskiy 3, Lenin 2
Sokolnikov 1
Postyshev 3, Dzerzhinskiy 2
Shepilov 1 (2.13 previous votes), Malenkov 1 (1.07 previous vote)
Rashidov 2 (4.53 previous votes), Grechko 2 (0.9 previous vote)
Chebrikov 4, Romanov 3
Shelepin 2 (1.9 previous vote), Kozlov 2 (1.2 previous vote)

Round 6:
Lenin 2
Radek 2, Bukharin 1, Rykov 1
Vyshinskiy 3, Dzerzhinskiy 2
Pervukhin 2, Malenkov 1
Kuznetsov 2, Grechko 1, Gromyko 1
Romanov 4, Zaykov 2, Kirilenko 1
Kozlov 2, Podgorniy 1

Rules are different in each round: please read the rules before voting.
The Politburo member who receives the biggest total of votes or points is purged.
In case of a tie, the Politburo member who has received the biggest total of previous votes is purged.
In case of a new tie, I, GenSek of this survivor, decide who is purged.

ROUND 7 IS OPEN !

Beware !In this round, you have 1 vote in each group, to cast 0.75 / 0.25 between 2 Politburo members.
We'll purge 1 Politburo member in EACH group.

Beware !
Logged
big bad fab
filliatre
Atlas Icon
*****
Posts: 13,344
Ukraine


Show only this user's posts in this thread
« Reply #39 on: June 09, 2010, 05:17:49 AM »

Sorry for my erratic updating of round number... But I see the "loyal" voters are still here Wink

0.75 Chubar / 0.25 Rudzutak (Chubar is less "original" than Rudzutak)

0.75 Tukhachevskiy / 0.25 Bukharin (Tukhachevskiy was a good marshal but not a democrat niether a fine "politician"; and Bukharin was, I think, the less kind of the 3 "rightists")

0.75 Kaganovich / 0.25 Andreyev (well, I'm a bit ashamed not voting for "Iron Feliks" Tongue ... but Kaganovich and Andreyev were the most loyal Stalinists, both evil and dull)

0.75 Bulganin / 0.25 Malenkov (it's really difficult here: Kuybyshev was a very serious and harsh guy and his "mysterious" death - not so mysterious of course - is a "fine" end; Kirov and Ordzhonikidze have fascinating careers and ends also; Malenkov could have made history, in economy and international relations, but he was a coward and was always overestimated; I don't hate Bulganin at all, but he is the least interesting here)

0.75 Ustinov / 0.25 Gromyko (Ustinov really became a paragon of brezhnevian "icing" and he wasn't a bright guy; Gromyko was a nasty human being, but he helped Gorbachev prevailing over Grishin in the end: I've never liked Gromyko but he has a "special" career...)

0.75 Zaykov / 0.25 Kosygin (Zaykov is the least interesting of the lot and, well, I still try to save Kirilenko Wink; Kosygin is really overvalued and was very harsh in political and international matters)

0.75 Podgorniy / 0.25 Yeltsin (a disappointing and unimportant guy; an erratic and, first, not so efficient one, if we take into account his Soviet period: I don't judge the Russian president here, but the regional satrap; of course Yeltsin was used by Gorbachev to appear centrist and was funny when he was party head in Moscow, but we have to pick someone...)
Logged
Chancellor Tanterterg
Mr. X
Moderators
Atlas Star
*****
Posts: 26,201
United States


Show only this user's posts in this thread
« Reply #40 on: June 09, 2010, 07:18:25 AM »

Bolsheviks
.75 CHUBAR/.25 PREOBRAZHENSKIY

Open Bolsheviks
.75 BUKHARIN/.25 RYKOV

Stalinists
.75 Kaganovich /.25 Andreyev (Got to protect Dzerzhinskiy!)

Open Stalinists
.75 Bulganin/.25 MALENKOV

Brezhnevians
.75 GRECHKO/.25 USTINOV

Modern conservatives
.75 KOSYGIN/.25 ZAYKOV (I guess Kirilenko can stay Wink )

Khrushchevians
.75 SHEVARDNADZE/.25 PODGORNIY
Logged
Hans-im-Glück
Franken
Junior Chimp
*****
Posts: 7,970
Germany


Political Matrix
E: -5.94, S: -3.30

Show only this user's posts in this thread
« Reply #41 on: June 09, 2010, 09:40:59 AM »

Bolsheviks
0.75 PREOBRAZHENSKIY/0.25 CHUBAR

Open Bolsheviks
0.75 RYKOV/0.25 BUKHARIN

Stalinists
0.75 DZERZHINSKIY /0.25 MOLOTOV

Open Stalinists
0.75 BULGANIN/0.25 MALENKOV

Brezhnevians
0.75 GROMYKO/0.25 SUSLOV

Modern conservatives
0.75 KIRILENKO/0.25 KOSYGIN

Khrushchevians
0.75 PODGORNIY/0.25  YELTSIN
Logged
Edu
Ufokart
Junior Chimp
*****
Posts: 7,864
Argentina


Show only this user's posts in this thread
« Reply #42 on: June 09, 2010, 01:38:09 PM »

Bolsheviks
0.75 for Vlas CHUBAR/0.25 for Yevgeniy PREOBRAZHENSKIY

Open Bolsheviks
0.75 for Nikolay BUKHARIN/0.25 for Aleksey RYKOV

Stalinists
0.75 for Lazar KAGANOVICH/0.25 for Andrey ANDREYEV 

Open Stalinists
0.75 for Nikolay BULGANIN/0.25 for Georgiy MALENKOV

Brezhnevians
0.75 for Dmitriy USTINOV/0.25 for Andrey GRECHKO

Modern conservatives
0.75 for Andrey KIRILENKO/0.25 for Pyotr SHELEST

Khrushchevians
0.75 for Nikolay PODGORNIY/0.25 for Boris YELTSIN
Logged
big bad fab
filliatre
Atlas Icon
*****
Posts: 13,344
Ukraine


Show only this user's posts in this thread
« Reply #43 on: June 10, 2010, 04:13:45 AM »
« Edited: June 10, 2010, 04:17:29 AM by big bad fab »

Should I delete this thread ? Grin
Kirilenko is out... what can I say... time for revenge Cheesy
What is more, with this stupid basket-baller Andrei Kirilenko, I was unable to find a photo of Andrei Kirilenko (the real one) alone. So, it's just a photo of the 1981 Politburo (Kirilenko is just to the right of Gromyko)

Well, poor Bulganin: no previous votes and he is now unanimously purged !
The "stalinist" group begins to be interesting as we've got real bad guys (Feliks, Zhdanov, Molotov, Andreyev) and that it seems that we have some entrenched camps...

A big name is out with Bukharin but, indeed, his "good" image is mostly due to reaction to what Stalin did towards him. Bukharin wasn't especially a kind guy and a democratic one.

Grechko and Gromyko are still here but for how long ?
BTW, jdb, why these votes against Grechko ? He was more a professionnal and a technician (not a bad one, even if its by Soviet standards...) and he was probably more moderate than, say, Kosygin, on international matters (or on Czechoslovakia 1968 for example). Just out of curiosity...


"Bolsheviks":
Vladimir Ulyanov LENIN (1917-1924)
Lev Bronstein TROTSKIY (1917-1926)
Mikhail Ivanovich KALININ (1919-1946)
Yakov SVERDLOV (1918-1919)
Yelena STASOVA (1917-1918, 1919)
Yevgeniy PREOBRAZHENSKIY (1917-1918, 1920-1921)
Yan RUDZUTAK (1926-1932, 1934-1938)
Stanislav KOSIOR (1927-1939)
Vlas CHUBAR (1926-1938)


"Open bolsheviks":
Lev Rozenfeld KAMENEV (1917-1926)
Grigoriy Radomyslskiy ZINOVYEV (1917-1926)
Nikolay BUKHARIN (1917-1929)
Aleksey RYKOV (1922-1930)
Mikhail TOMSKIY (1922-1930)
Nikolay KRESTINSKIY (1917-1921)
Mikhail FRUNZE (1924-1925)
Grigoriy Brilliant SOKOLNIKOV (1917-1919)
Karl RADEK (-)
Mikhail TUKHACHEVSKIY (-)


"Stalinists":
Iosif Dzhugashvili STALIN (1917-1953)
Vyacheslav Skryabin MOLOTOV (1921-1957)
Kliment VOROSHILOV (1926-1960)
Lazar KAGANOVICH (1926-1957)
Feliks DZERZHINSKIY (1918-1919, 1924-1926)
Andrey ZHDANOV (1935-1948)
Nikolay YEZHOV (1937-1938)
Andrey ANDREYEV (1926-1930, 1932-1952)
Lavrentiy BERIYA (1939-1953)
Andrey VYSHINSKIY (1952-1953)
Pavel POSTYSHEV (1934-1938)
Genrikh YAGODA (-)


"Open stalinists":
Georgiy MALENKOV (1941-1957)
Nikolay BULGANIN (1946-1958)
Anastas MIKOYAN (1926-1966)
Dmitriy SHEPILOV (1956-1957)
Sergey Kostrikov KIROV (1926-1934)
Maksim SABUROV (1952-1957)
Mikhail PERVUKHIN (1952-1961)
Nikolay VOZNESENSKIY (1941-1949)
Georgiy ZHUKOV (1956-1957)
Grigori Sergo ORDZHONIKIDZE (1930-1937)
Valerian KUYBYSHEV (1927-1935)


"Brezhnevians":
Leonid BREZHNEV (1952-1953, 1957-1982)
Konstantin CHERNENKO (1977-1985)
Nikolay TIKHONOV (1978-1985)
Andrey GROMYKO (1973-1988)
Vasiliy KUZNETSOV (1952-1953, 1977-1986)
Mikhail SUSLOV (1952-1953, 1955-1982)
Dmitriy USTINOV (1965-1984)
Andrey GRECHKO (1973-1976)
Vladimir SHCHERBITSKIY (1961-1963, 1965-1989)
Viktor GRISHIN (1961-1986)
Sharaf RASHIDOV (1961-1983)
Boris PONOMAREV (1972-1986)


"Modern conservatives":
Aleksey KOSYGIN (1946-1953, 1957-1980)
Andrey KIRILENKO (1957-1961, 1962-1982)
Grigoriy ROMANOV (1973-1985)
Nikolay RYZHKOV (1985-1990)
Gennadiy YANAYEV (1990-1991)
Anatoliy LUKYANOV (1988-1990)
Yegor LIGACHEV (1985-1990)
Lev ZAYKOV (1986-1990)
Viktor CHEBRIKOV (1983-1989)
Vladimir KRYUCHKOV (1989-1990)
Heidar ALIYEV (1976-1987)
Pyotr SHELEST (1963-1973)
Valentin PAVLOV (-)


"Khrushchevians":
Nikita Sergeyevich KHRUSHCHEV (1938-1964)
Yuriy ANDROPOV (1967-1984)
Nikolay PODGORNIY (1958-1977)
Nikolay SHVERNIK (1939-1966)
Aleksandr SHELEPIN (1964-1975)
Frol KOZLOV (1956-1964)
Fyodor KULAKOV (1971-1978)
Dmitriy POLYANSKIY (1958-1976)
Otto KUUSINEN (1952-1953, 1957-1964)
Mikhail GORBACHEV (1979-1991)
Aleksandr YAKOVLEV (1987-1990)
Eduard SHEVARDNADZE (1978-1990)
Boris YELTSIN (1986-1988)

Results:

Round 1:
Kosior 1.67, Lenin 1.33, Trotskiy 1.33, Kalinin 0.67, Sverdlov 0.67, Chubar 0.33
Krestinskiy 1.33 (+ GenSek's decision), Frunze 1.33, Zinovyev 1.33, Kamenev 0.67, Rykov 0.67, Bukharin 0.33, Sokolnikov 1
Stalin 3.33, Yezhov 1, Postyshev 0.67, Beriya 0.33, Kaganovich 0.33, Yagoda 0.33
Zhukov 1.67 (+ GenSek's decision), Mikoyan 1.67, Bulganin 1, Malenkov 0.67, Kuybyshev 0.33, Ordzhonikidze 0.33, Shepilov 0.33
Chernenko 2.67, Brezhnev 1.33, Gromyko 0.67, Shcherbitskiy 0.67, Rashidov 0.33, Suslov 0.33
Yanayev 1.33 (+ GenSek's decision), Aliyev 1.33, Kirilenko 1.33, Kosygin 1.33, Pavlov 0.67, Ryzhkov 0.33
Shvernik 2.67, Polyanskiy 1.67, Khrushchev 0.67, Yeltsin 0.67, Andropov 0.33

Round 2:
Stasova 1.5, Kalinin 1, Troskiy 0.5, Sverdlov 0.5 (-1), Lenin 0.5 (-3)
Zinovyev 1.5, Frunze 1 (-1), Kamenev 1 (-1), Sokolnikov 0.5, Radek 0 (-1)
Yezhov 1.5, Postyshev 1, Beriya 1 (-1), Yagoda 0.5 (-1), Dzerzhinskiy 0 (-1), Zhdanov 0 (-1)
Saburov 1.5 (-1 + GenSek's decision), Mikoyan 1.5 (-1), Kuybyshev 0.5, Voznesenskiy 0.5, Kirov 0 (-1), Ordzhonikidze 0 (-1)
Shcherbitskiy 1 (0), Rashidov 1 (-1), Grechko 0.5, Gromyko 0.5, Brezhnev 0.5 (-1), Tikhonov 0.5 (-1), Suslov 0 (-1)
Aliyev 1.5 (-1 + GenSek's decision), Kirilenko 1.5 (-1), Pavlov 1 (-2)
Polyanskiy 2, Khrushchev 1 (-1), Kuusinen 0.5, Shelepin 0.5, Yakovlev 0 (-1), Andropov 0 (-2)

Round 3:
Sverdlov 3, Kalinin 1, Lenin 1
Kamenev 3, Frunze 2
Beriya 1, Kaganovich 1, Postyshev 1, Yagoda 1
Mikoyan 3, Shepilov 1, Voznesensky 1
Brezhnev 2 (1.83 previous vote), Rashidov 2 (1.33 previous vote), Gromyko 1
Pavlov 3, Kirilenko 2
Khrushchev 2, Gorbachev 1, Kuusinen 1, Shelepin 1

Round 4:
Kalinin 1.6, Chubar 1, Trotskiy 0.8, Lenin 0.6
Frunze 1.4 (4.33 previous votes), Sokolnikov 1.4 (1.5 previous votes), Radek 1, Tukhachevskiy 0.2
Yagoda 1.4, Kaganovich 1.2, Postyshev 0.8, Vyshinskiy 0.4, Zhdanov 0.2
Voznesesnkiy 1.2, Ordzhonikidze 0.8, Shepilov 0.8, Pervukhin 0.6, Malenkov 0.4, Kuybyshev 0.2
Tikhonov 1.4, Rashidov 1.2, Kuznetsov 0.6, Grechko 0.4, Gromyko 0.4
Kryuchkov 1.6, Kirilenko 0.8, Romanov 0.8, Chebrikov 0.6, Kosygin 0.2
Kuusinen 1.4, Kozlov 1.2, Podgorniy 1, Shelepin 0.4

Round 5:
Trotskiy 3, Lenin 2
Sokolnikov 1
Postyshev 3, Dzerzhinskiy 2
Shepilov 1 (2.13 previous votes), Malenkov 1 (1.07 previous vote)
Rashidov 2 (4.53 previous votes), Grechko 2 (0.9 previous vote)
Chebrikov 4, Romanov 3
Shelepin 2 (1.9 previous vote), Kozlov 2 (1.2 previous vote)

Round 6:
Lenin 2
Radek 2, Bukharin 1, Rykov 1
Vyshinskiy 3, Dzerzhinskiy 2
Pervukhin 2, Malenkov 1
Kuznetsov 2, Grechko 1, Gromyko 1
Romanov 4, Zaykov 2, Kirilenko 1
Kozlov 2, Podgorniy 1

Round 7:
Chubar 2.5, Preobrazhenskiy 1.25, Rudzutak 0.25
Bukharin 2, Rykov 1.25, Tukhachevskiy 0.75
Kaganovich 2.25, Andreyev 0.75, Dzerzhinskiy 0.75, Molotov 0.25
Bulganin 3, Malenkov 1
Ustinov 1.75, Grechko 1, Gromyko 1, Suslov 0.25
Kirilenko 1.5, Kosygin 1.25, Zaykov 1, Shelest 0.25
Podgorniy 2.5, Shevardnadze 0.75, Yeltsin 0.75

Rules are different in each round: please read the rules before voting.
The Politburo member who receives the biggest total of votes or points is purged.
In case of a tie, the Politburo member who has received the biggest total of previous votes is purged.
In case of a new tie, I, GenSek of this survivor, decide who is purged.

ROUND 8 IS OPEN !

Beware !In this round, you vote for 6 Politburo members from at least 4 different groups.
We'll purge the 4 Politburo members who receive the biggest total of votes.

Beware !
Logged
big bad fab
filliatre
Atlas Icon
*****
Posts: 13,344
Ukraine


Show only this user's posts in this thread
« Reply #44 on: June 10, 2010, 04:29:25 AM »

Preobrazhenskiy

Andreyev
Molotov
Dzerzhinskiy

(yes... this rule forces to make tough decisions I think)

Gromyko

Zaykov

(I have even considered voting for Ordzhonikidze ! Amazing !)
Logged
Edu
Ufokart
Junior Chimp
*****
Posts: 7,864
Argentina


Show only this user's posts in this thread
« Reply #45 on: June 10, 2010, 10:33:24 AM »

Don't talk of revenge fab. Kirilenko was my revenge for Lenin. Now we are even Grin


Bolsheviks
Yevgeniy PREOBRAZHENSKIY

Stalinists
Andrey ANDREYEV

Open stalinists
Georgiy MALENKOV

Brezhnevians
Andrey GROMYKO
Andrey GRECHKO

Modern conservatives
Lev ZAYKOV

No votes in Open bolsheviks and Khrushchevians. Did i get the rules right fab?
Logged
Chancellor Tanterterg
Mr. X
Moderators
Atlas Star
*****
Posts: 26,201
United States


Show only this user's posts in this thread
« Reply #46 on: June 10, 2010, 11:55:32 AM »

Bolsheviks
No Vote (Preobrazhenskiy will probably be eliminated even without my vote)

Open Bolsheviks
No Vote

Stalinists
ANDREYEV (Got to protect Dzerzhinskiy!)
MOLOTOV (Anticipating next round)
ZHDANOV (Back up plan for the next round)

Open Stalinists
MALENKOV

Brezhnevians
GRECHKO (He must go before Gromyko Wink )

Modern conservatives
ZAYKOV (boring one)

Khrushchevians
No Vote
Logged
big bad fab
filliatre
Atlas Icon
*****
Posts: 13,344
Ukraine


Show only this user's posts in this thread
« Reply #47 on: June 10, 2010, 05:32:12 PM »
« Edited: June 11, 2010, 07:26:23 AM by big bad fab »

It's OK, Edu.
A bit too sophisticated, eh ? Wink
I don't even anticipate well the real effect of my rules... At least, that's funny.


Oh, and about revenge... given what you say, let's talk about "vendetta" now Grin
So, for Kirilenko (and Shelepin, which is almost worse Wink), I'll pursue a revenge forever !
Logged
big bad fab
filliatre
Atlas Icon
*****
Posts: 13,344
Ukraine


Show only this user's posts in this thread
« Reply #48 on: June 14, 2010, 02:27:44 AM »

What do you think, Edu and jdb, should I keep on ?
We are just 4 and I think we can't afford losing another one, even for 1 or 2 rounds.
But if you want me to update quickly, no problem.
Logged
Chancellor Tanterterg
Mr. X
Moderators
Atlas Star
*****
Posts: 26,201
United States


Show only this user's posts in this thread
« Reply #49 on: June 14, 2010, 09:37:26 AM »

Please keep it up, I've really been enjoying this survivor!
Logged
Pages: 1 [2] 3 4 5 6 7 ... 9  
« previous next »
Jump to:  


Login with username, password and session length

Terms of Service - DMCA Agent and Policy - Privacy Policy and Cookies

Powered by SMF 1.1.21 | SMF © 2015, Simple Machines

Page created in 0.153 seconds with 12 queries.