Ah, too much new territory in that map for the Pub incumbents, and at least Marsha Blackburn (unless she runs in TN-05 rather than TN-07), if not others, have been drawn out of their home. My map above does the job the way I think it is more likely to be done. My map went for the max without going over the edge (it was a very careful balancing test), but whether the Pubs will go so far as to make TN-05 a 55% McCain CD remains to be seen. They may be more cautious, to not get quite so close to the "responsible edge."
Your pet name for Republicans is pretty creepy. Pubbie? Really?
I've never taken incumbent residency into account in any map I've drawn. I don't care about incumbents
Splitting a city into two districts doesn't "destroy a community of interest." It's a partisan play. All of downtown Nashville is in the yellow district. Let's compare my split of Davidson Co, and the Dems shreading of Baltimore City/Co and see which one is better..