2010 Defeated US House Incumbents Survivor TOM PERRIELLO IS SURVIVOR!

[Chancellor Tanterterg]

Eliminate
10 Grayson

Keep
5 Patrick Murphy

[Vazdul (Formerly Chairman of the Communist Party of Ontario)]

Kagen 12
Grayson 11
Cao 6
Scott Murphy 5
Patrick Murphy 5
Inglis -2
Space -2
Perriello -5

THE TOP 15:

Joseph Cao (R, LA-2)
Steve Driehaus (D, OH-1) ELIMINATED ROUND 17
Chet Edwards (D, TX-17)
Bill Foster (D, IL-14)
Alan Grayson (D, FL-8)
Baron Hill (D, IN-9)
Bob Inglis (R, SC-4)
Steven Kagen (D, WI-8) ELIMINATED ROUND 18
Patrick Murphy (D, PA-8)
Scott Murphy (D, NY-20)
Tom Perriello (D, VA-5)
Earl Pomeroy (D, ND-AL)
Ciro Rodriguez (D, TX-23)
Carol Shea-Porter (D, NH-1)
Zack Space (D, OH-18)

ROUND 1 RESULTS: Griffith 12, Kilpatrick 8, Taylor 5, Oberstar 2, Hare 1, Bright 1, Skelton 1, Kanjorski 0, Sandlin -1, Minnick -3, Cao -3, Shea-Porter -4
ROUND 2 RESULTS: Mollohan 8, Hare 6, Skelton 5, Ortiz 4, Marshall 2, Boucher 2, Oberstar 2, Bright -1, Sandlin -1, Kanjorski -1, Cao -3, Minnick -3
ROUND 3 RESULTS: Ortiz 9, Oberstar 8, Kanjorski 8, Bright 7, Halvorson 5, Kosmas 2, Marshall 2, Davis 2, Etheridge 1, Grayson 1, Hall -1, Shea-Porter -1, Scott Murphy -1, Perriello -1, Boucher -2, Rodriguez -3, Sandlin -3, Cao -3
ROUND 4 RESULTS: Davis 11, Bright 9, Halvorson 8, Spratt 5, Marshall 4, Boucher 2, Kosmas 2, Etheridge -1, Sandlin -1, Bean -2, Grayson -3, Teague -4, Cao -5
ROUND 5 RESULTS: Spratt 9, Marshall 6, Boucher 5, Bean 4, Kosmas 2, Kratovil 2, McMahon 2, Etheridge 1, Sandlin -1, Teague -1, Hall -2, Minnick -2
ROUND 6 RESULTS: McMahon 12, Nye 8, Kosmas 5 (6 eliminate points in the current round), Kratovil 5 (5 eliminate points in the current round), Childers 2, Sandlin 0, Cao 0, Teague 0, Minnick 0, Etheridge 0, Hall -1, Bean -2, Perriello -4
ROUND 7 RESULTS: Kratovil 13, Childers 6, Teague 5, Bean 3, Minnick 1, Etheridge 1, Rodriguez -2, Cao -3, Sandlin -4
ROUND 8 RESULTS: Minnick 8, Kilroy 8, Sandlin 6, Bean 5, Etheridge 2, Grayson 1, Djou 1, Foster 1, Cao -1, Boccieri -1, Space -4
ROUND 9 RESULTS: Bean 10, Boyd 6, Etheridge 4, Foster 3, Klein 2, Adler 2, Boccieri 1, Djou -1, Cao -7
ROUND 10 RESULTS: Adler 9, Titus 4, Arcuri 4, Boccieri 3, Markey 3, Klein 2, Maffei 2, Hall 1, Scott Murphy 1, Salazar -1, Cao -2, Carney -2, Foster -3, Space -3, Grayson -3
ROUND 11 RESULTS: Markey 7, Boccieri 7, Klein 6, Wilson 4, Maffei 2, Hall 1, Space -1, Cao -1, Salazar -1, Scott Murphy -2, Perriello -2, Foster -5
ROUND 12 RESULTS: Maffei 10, Djou 9, Kirkpatrick 8, Grayson 6, Schauer 3, Wilson 3, Salazar -1, Space -1, Cao -2, Perriello -2, Hall -4, Foster -4
ROUND 13 RESULTS: Wilson 14, Kirkpatrick 11, Schauer 4, Carney 3, Cao -1, Foster -2, Inglis -3, Grayson -6
ROUND 14 RESULTS: Schauer 18, Carney 7, Dahlkemper 4, Grayson 3, Hall 2, Inglis -2, Foster -3, Cao -4
ROUND 15 RESULTS: Dahlkemper 16, Mitchell 4 (4 eliminate points this round, no points in previous rounds), Hall 4 (4 eliminate points this round, -4 points in previous rounds), Patrick Murphy 3, Foster 0, Inglis -1, Grayson -1, Cao -2, Scott Murphy -3
ROUND 16 RESULTS: Hall 15, Salazar 6, Patrick Murphy 5, Scott Murphy 4, Space 4, Kagen 2, Inglis -2, Cao -2, Grayson -12
ROUND 17 RESULTS: Driehaus 10, Patrick Murphy 9, Scott Murphy 7, Kagen 5, Foster 3, Cao -1, Inglis -2, Space -2, Grayson -9
ROUND 18 RESULTS: Kagen 12, Grayson 11, Cao 6, Scott Murphy 5, Patrick Murphy 5, Inglis -2, Space -2, Perriello -5

POINTS IN PREVIOUS ROUNDS: Patrick Murphy 22, Scott Murphy 11, Shea-Porter -5, Rodriguez -5, Space -9, Foster -10, Inglis -12, Grayson -12, Perriello -14, Cao -34

Round 19 is open, and will close no earlier than 3:00 PM Eastern Time on Monday, January 31st. Remember that you have ten “eliminate” points, divided as you choose among ANY NUMBER of defeated incumbents, and five “keep” points, divided as you choose among any number of defeated incumbents. The one with the most points will be eliminated.

[big bad fab]

Eliminate
7 Scott Murphy
3 Alan Grayson

Keep
3 Joseph Cao
1 Bob Inglis
1 Earl Pomeroy

[minionofmidas]

Eliminate 10 Bob Inglis

Keep 3 Ciro Rodriguez, 1 Alan Grayson, 1 Earl Pomeroy

[homelycooking]

Grayson is far too interesting to be eliminated for 12th place.

Eliminate

Patrick Murphy 5
Scott Murphy 5

Keep

Alan Grayson 5

[Nhoj]

Eliminate
7 Alan Grayson
3 Patrick Murphy

Keep
5 Bob Inglis

[big bad fab]

Personally, I don't really want to oust Grayson now, but I want some voters to help me in the elimination of Scott Murphy, so I guess it's a way to reach my goal (and, of course, these points for Grayson may be useful when we near the top 5, as I think he would be fine in 6th place ).

Of course, all these calculations are for fun (and for the fun to write them and to be read), as we've got one-time 10-point voters who blast every hypothesis in just one round

[minionofmidas]

Of course, all these calculations are for fun (and for the fun to write them and to be read), as we've got one-time 10-point voters who blast every hypothesis in just one round

I might keep voting. Who knows.

[big bad fab]

Of course, all these calculations are for fun (and for the fun to write them and to be read), as we've got one-time 10-point voters who blast every hypothesis in just one round

I might keep voting. Who knows.

Yay, plus on est de fous, plus on rit .

[Edu]

Eliminate
8 for Scott Murphy
2 for Patrick Murphy

Keep
5 for Alan Grayson

[Niemeyerite]

5 cao
5 alan grayson


keep:

5 scott murphy (LOL)

[Vazdul (Formerly Chairman of the Communist Party of Ontario)]

Scott Murphy 15
Patrick Murphy 10
Inglis 4
Grayson 4
Cao 2
Pomeroy -2
Rodriguez -3

THE TOP 15:

Joseph Cao (R, LA-2)
Steve Driehaus (D, OH-1) ELIMINATED ROUND 17
Chet Edwards (D, TX-17)
Bill Foster (D, IL-14)
Alan Grayson (D, FL-8)
Baron Hill (D, IN-9)
Bob Inglis (R, SC-4)
Steven Kagen (D, WI-8) ELIMINATED ROUND 18
Patrick Murphy (D, PA-8)
Scott Murphy (D, NY-20) ELIMINATED ROUND 19
Tom Perriello (D, VA-5)
Earl Pomeroy (D, ND-AL)
Ciro Rodriguez (D, TX-23)
Carol Shea-Porter (D, NH-1)
Zack Space (D, OH-18)

ROUND 1 RESULTS: Griffith 12, Kilpatrick 8, Taylor 5, Oberstar 2, Hare 1, Bright 1, Skelton 1, Kanjorski 0, Sandlin -1, Minnick -3, Cao -3, Shea-Porter -4
ROUND 2 RESULTS: Mollohan 8, Hare 6, Skelton 5, Ortiz 4, Marshall 2, Boucher 2, Oberstar 2, Bright -1, Sandlin -1, Kanjorski -1, Cao -3, Minnick -3
ROUND 3 RESULTS: Ortiz 9, Oberstar 8, Kanjorski 8, Bright 7, Halvorson 5, Kosmas 2, Marshall 2, Davis 2, Etheridge 1, Grayson 1, Hall -1, Shea-Porter -1, Scott Murphy -1, Perriello -1, Boucher -2, Rodriguez -3, Sandlin -3, Cao -3
ROUND 4 RESULTS: Davis 11, Bright 9, Halvorson 8, Spratt 5, Marshall 4, Boucher 2, Kosmas 2, Etheridge -1, Sandlin -1, Bean -2, Grayson -3, Teague -4, Cao -5
ROUND 5 RESULTS: Spratt 9, Marshall 6, Boucher 5, Bean 4, Kosmas 2, Kratovil 2, McMahon 2, Etheridge 1, Sandlin -1, Teague -1, Hall -2, Minnick -2
ROUND 6 RESULTS: McMahon 12, Nye 8, Kosmas 5 (6 eliminate points in the current round), Kratovil 5 (5 eliminate points in the current round), Childers 2, Sandlin 0, Cao 0, Teague 0, Minnick 0, Etheridge 0, Hall -1, Bean -2, Perriello -4
ROUND 7 RESULTS: Kratovil 13, Childers 6, Teague 5, Bean 3, Minnick 1, Etheridge 1, Rodriguez -2, Cao -3, Sandlin -4
ROUND 8 RESULTS: Minnick 8, Kilroy 8, Sandlin 6, Bean 5, Etheridge 2, Grayson 1, Djou 1, Foster 1, Cao -1, Boccieri -1, Space -4
ROUND 9 RESULTS: Bean 10, Boyd 6, Etheridge 4, Foster 3, Klein 2, Adler 2, Boccieri 1, Djou -1, Cao -7
ROUND 10 RESULTS: Adler 9, Titus 4, Arcuri 4, Boccieri 3, Markey 3, Klein 2, Maffei 2, Hall 1, Scott Murphy 1, Salazar -1, Cao -2, Carney -2, Foster -3, Space -3, Grayson -3
ROUND 11 RESULTS: Markey 7, Boccieri 7, Klein 6, Wilson 4, Maffei 2, Hall 1, Space -1, Cao -1, Salazar -1, Scott Murphy -2, Perriello -2, Foster -5
ROUND 12 RESULTS: Maffei 10, Djou 9, Kirkpatrick 8, Grayson 6, Schauer 3, Wilson 3, Salazar -1, Space -1, Cao -2, Perriello -2, Hall -4, Foster -4
ROUND 13 RESULTS: Wilson 14, Kirkpatrick 11, Schauer 4, Carney 3, Cao -1, Foster -2, Inglis -3, Grayson -6
ROUND 14 RESULTS: Schauer 18, Carney 7, Dahlkemper 4, Grayson 3, Hall 2, Inglis -2, Foster -3, Cao -4
ROUND 15 RESULTS: Dahlkemper 16, Mitchell 4 (4 eliminate points this round, no points in previous rounds), Hall 4 (4 eliminate points this round, -4 points in previous rounds), Patrick Murphy 3, Foster 0, Inglis -1, Grayson -1, Cao -2, Scott Murphy -3
ROUND 16 RESULTS: Hall 15, Salazar 6, Patrick Murphy 5, Scott Murphy 4, Space 4, Kagen 2, Inglis -2, Cao -2, Grayson -12
ROUND 17 RESULTS: Driehaus 10, Patrick Murphy 9, Scott Murphy 7, Kagen 5, Foster 3, Cao -1, Inglis -2, Space -2, Grayson -9
ROUND 18 RESULTS: Kagen 12, Grayson 11, Cao 6, Scott Murphy 5, Patrick Murphy 5, Inglis -2, Space -2, Perriello -5
ROUND 19 RESULTS: Scott Murphy 15, Patrick Murphy 10, Inglis 4, Grayson 4, Cao 2, Pomeroy -2, Rodriguez -3

POINTS IN PREVIOUS ROUNDS: Patrick Murphy 32, Pomeroy -2, Shea-Porter -5, Rodriguez -8, Inglis -8, Grayson -8, Space -9, Foster -10, Perriello -14, Cao -32

Round 20 is open, and will close no earlier than 5:30 PM Eastern Time on Tuesday, February 1st. Remember that you have ten “eliminate” points, divided as you choose among ANY NUMBER of defeated incumbents, and five “keep” points, divided as you choose among any number of defeated incumbents. The one with the most points will be eliminated.

[homelycooking]

I wish I didn't have to do this, but it's only to save Grayson.

Eliminate

10 Patrick Murphy

Keep

5 Alan Grayson

[big bad fab]

Eliminate
10 Carol Shea-Porter

Keep
3 Bob Inglis
2 Earl Pomeroy

[minionofmidas]

10 Inglis

---

3 Shea-Porter (just to even the playing field again! They're both incompetents who ought to have gone a long time ago, really.)
2 Pat Murphy

[Nhoj]

Eliminate

8 Alan Grayson
2 Zack Space
Keep

5 Bob Inglis

[Niemeyerite]

eliminate
10 cao

keep

3 grayson
2 inglis

[big bad fab]

And now, we are all forced to vote with a pack of 10 points

[Edu]

Well, since everybody's doing it

Eliminate
10 for Carol Shea-Porter

Keep
5 for Alan Grayson

[Vazdul (Formerly Chairman of the Communist Party of Ontario)]

Shea-Porter 17
Cao 10
Patrick Murphy 8
Space 2
Inglis 0
Pomeroy -2
Grayson -5

THE TOP 15:

Joseph Cao (R, LA-2)
Steve Driehaus (D, OH-1) ELIMINATED ROUND 17
Chet Edwards (D, TX-17)
Bill Foster (D, IL-14)
Alan Grayson (D, FL-8)
Baron Hill (D, IN-9)
Bob Inglis (R, SC-4)
Steven Kagen (D, WI-8) ELIMINATED ROUND 18
Patrick Murphy (D, PA-8)
Scott Murphy (D, NY-20) ELIMINATED ROUND 19
Tom Perriello (D, VA-5)
Earl Pomeroy (D, ND-AL)
Ciro Rodriguez (D, TX-23)
Carol Shea-Porter (D, NH-1) ELIMINATED ROUND 20
Zack Space (D, OH-18)

ROUND 1 RESULTS: Griffith 12, Kilpatrick 8, Taylor 5, Oberstar 2, Hare 1, Bright 1, Skelton 1, Kanjorski 0, Sandlin -1, Minnick -3, Cao -3, Shea-Porter -4
ROUND 2 RESULTS: Mollohan 8, Hare 6, Skelton 5, Ortiz 4, Marshall 2, Boucher 2, Oberstar 2, Bright -1, Sandlin -1, Kanjorski -1, Cao -3, Minnick -3
ROUND 3 RESULTS: Ortiz 9, Oberstar 8, Kanjorski 8, Bright 7, Halvorson 5, Kosmas 2, Marshall 2, Davis 2, Etheridge 1, Grayson 1, Hall -1, Shea-Porter -1, Scott Murphy -1, Perriello -1, Boucher -2, Rodriguez -3, Sandlin -3, Cao -3
ROUND 4 RESULTS: Davis 11, Bright 9, Halvorson 8, Spratt 5, Marshall 4, Boucher 2, Kosmas 2, Etheridge -1, Sandlin -1, Bean -2, Grayson -3, Teague -4, Cao -5
ROUND 5 RESULTS: Spratt 9, Marshall 6, Boucher 5, Bean 4, Kosmas 2, Kratovil 2, McMahon 2, Etheridge 1, Sandlin -1, Teague -1, Hall -2, Minnick -2
ROUND 6 RESULTS: McMahon 12, Nye 8, Kosmas 5 (6 eliminate points in the current round), Kratovil 5 (5 eliminate points in the current round), Childers 2, Sandlin 0, Cao 0, Teague 0, Minnick 0, Etheridge 0, Hall -1, Bean -2, Perriello -4
ROUND 7 RESULTS: Kratovil 13, Childers 6, Teague 5, Bean 3, Minnick 1, Etheridge 1, Rodriguez -2, Cao -3, Sandlin -4
ROUND 8 RESULTS: Minnick 8, Kilroy 8, Sandlin 6, Bean 5, Etheridge 2, Grayson 1, Djou 1, Foster 1, Cao -1, Boccieri -1, Space -4
ROUND 9 RESULTS: Bean 10, Boyd 6, Etheridge 4, Foster 3, Klein 2, Adler 2, Boccieri 1, Djou -1, Cao -7
ROUND 10 RESULTS: Adler 9, Titus 4, Arcuri 4, Boccieri 3, Markey 3, Klein 2, Maffei 2, Hall 1, Scott Murphy 1, Salazar -1, Cao -2, Carney -2, Foster -3, Space -3, Grayson -3
ROUND 11 RESULTS: Markey 7, Boccieri 7, Klein 6, Wilson 4, Maffei 2, Hall 1, Space -1, Cao -1, Salazar -1, Scott Murphy -2, Perriello -2, Foster -5
ROUND 12 RESULTS: Maffei 10, Djou 9, Kirkpatrick 8, Grayson 6, Schauer 3, Wilson 3, Salazar -1, Space -1, Cao -2, Perriello -2, Hall -4, Foster -4
ROUND 13 RESULTS: Wilson 14, Kirkpatrick 11, Schauer 4, Carney 3, Cao -1, Foster -2, Inglis -3, Grayson -6
ROUND 14 RESULTS: Schauer 18, Carney 7, Dahlkemper 4, Grayson 3, Hall 2, Inglis -2, Foster -3, Cao -4
ROUND 15 RESULTS: Dahlkemper 16, Mitchell 4 (4 eliminate points this round, no points in previous rounds), Hall 4 (4 eliminate points this round, -4 points in previous rounds), Patrick Murphy 3, Foster 0, Inglis -1, Grayson -1, Cao -2, Scott Murphy -3
ROUND 16 RESULTS: Hall 15, Salazar 6, Patrick Murphy 5, Scott Murphy 4, Space 4, Kagen 2, Inglis -2, Cao -2, Grayson -12
ROUND 17 RESULTS: Driehaus 10, Patrick Murphy 9, Scott Murphy 7, Kagen 5, Foster 3, Cao -1, Inglis -2, Space -2, Grayson -9
ROUND 18 RESULTS: Kagen 12, Grayson 11, Cao 6, Scott Murphy 5, Patrick Murphy 5, Inglis -2, Space -2, Perriello -5
ROUND 19 RESULTS: Scott Murphy 15, Patrick Murphy 10, Inglis 4, Grayson 4, Cao 2, Pomeroy -2, Rodriguez -3
ROUND 20 RESULTS: Shea-Porter 17, Cao 10, Patrick Murphy 8, Space 2, Inglis 0, Pomeroy -2, Grayson -5

POINTS IN PREVIOUS ROUNDS: Patrick Murphy 40, Pomeroy -4, Space -7, Rodriguez -8, Inglis -8, Foster -10, Perriello -14, Grayson -13, Cao -22

Round 21 is open, and will close no earlier than 6:30 PM Eastern Time on Wednesday, February 2nd. Remember that you have ten “eliminate” points, divided as you choose among ANY NUMBER of defeated incumbents, and five “keep” points, divided as you choose among any number of defeated incumbents. The one with the most points will be eliminated.

[Nhoj]

10 Alan Grayson

Keep
5 Bob Inglis

[minionofmidas]

Just to even things out again

10 Bob Inglis

Keep
5 Alan Grayson

[big bad fab]

Eliminate
9 Patrick Murphy
1 Baron Hill

Keep
3 Bob Inglis
2 Joseph Cao

[Niemeyerite]

10 Cao

keep

5 Pat Murphy

[I spent the winter writing songs about getting better]

Eliminate Bob Inglis
Keep Alan Grayson