2010 Defeated US House Incumbents Survivor TOM PERRIELLO IS SURVIVOR!

[Vazdul (Formerly Chairman of the Communist Party of Ontario)]

Eliminate Bob Inglis
Keep Alan Grayson

Can I assume that that's 10 points to eliminate Inglis, and 5 to keep Grayson? (That seems like the only logical conclusion, but just to be sure...)

[Edu]

10 for Patrick Murphy

Keep
5 for Alan Grayson

[Vazdul (Formerly Chairman of the Communist Party of Ontario)]

I've decided to count BRTD's vote even though he didn't assign the points, because the intent was obvious.



Patrick Murphy 14
Inglis 12
Cao 8
Hill 1
Grayson -5

THE TOP 15:

Joseph Cao (R, LA-2)
Steve Driehaus (D, OH-1) ELIMINATED ROUND 17
Chet Edwards (D, TX-17)
Bill Foster (D, IL-14)
Alan Grayson (D, FL-8)
Baron Hill (D, IN-9)
Bob Inglis (R, SC-4)
Steven Kagen (D, WI-8) ELIMINATED ROUND 18
Patrick Murphy (D, PA-8) ELIMINATED ROUND 21
Scott Murphy (D, NY-20) ELIMINATED ROUND 19
Tom Perriello (D, VA-5)
Earl Pomeroy (D, ND-AL)
Ciro Rodriguez (D, TX-23)
Carol Shea-Porter (D, NH-1) ELIMINATED ROUND 20
Zack Space (D, OH-18)

ROUND 1 RESULTS: Griffith 12, Kilpatrick 8, Taylor 5, Oberstar 2, Hare 1, Bright 1, Skelton 1, Kanjorski 0, Sandlin -1, Minnick -3, Cao -3, Shea-Porter -4
ROUND 2 RESULTS: Mollohan 8, Hare 6, Skelton 5, Ortiz 4, Marshall 2, Boucher 2, Oberstar 2, Bright -1, Sandlin -1, Kanjorski -1, Cao -3, Minnick -3
ROUND 3 RESULTS: Ortiz 9, Oberstar 8, Kanjorski 8, Bright 7, Halvorson 5, Kosmas 2, Marshall 2, Davis 2, Etheridge 1, Grayson 1, Hall -1, Shea-Porter -1, Scott Murphy -1, Perriello -1, Boucher -2, Rodriguez -3, Sandlin -3, Cao -3
ROUND 4 RESULTS: Davis 11, Bright 9, Halvorson 8, Spratt 5, Marshall 4, Boucher 2, Kosmas 2, Etheridge -1, Sandlin -1, Bean -2, Grayson -3, Teague -4, Cao -5
ROUND 5 RESULTS: Spratt 9, Marshall 6, Boucher 5, Bean 4, Kosmas 2, Kratovil 2, McMahon 2, Etheridge 1, Sandlin -1, Teague -1, Hall -2, Minnick -2
ROUND 6 RESULTS: McMahon 12, Nye 8, Kosmas 5 (6 eliminate points in the current round), Kratovil 5 (5 eliminate points in the current round), Childers 2, Sandlin 0, Cao 0, Teague 0, Minnick 0, Etheridge 0, Hall -1, Bean -2, Perriello -4
ROUND 7 RESULTS: Kratovil 13, Childers 6, Teague 5, Bean 3, Minnick 1, Etheridge 1, Rodriguez -2, Cao -3, Sandlin -4
ROUND 8 RESULTS: Minnick 8, Kilroy 8, Sandlin 6, Bean 5, Etheridge 2, Grayson 1, Djou 1, Foster 1, Cao -1, Boccieri -1, Space -4
ROUND 9 RESULTS: Bean 10, Boyd 6, Etheridge 4, Foster 3, Klein 2, Adler 2, Boccieri 1, Djou -1, Cao -7
ROUND 10 RESULTS: Adler 9, Titus 4, Arcuri 4, Boccieri 3, Markey 3, Klein 2, Maffei 2, Hall 1, Scott Murphy 1, Salazar -1, Cao -2, Carney -2, Foster -3, Space -3, Grayson -3
ROUND 11 RESULTS: Markey 7, Boccieri 7, Klein 6, Wilson 4, Maffei 2, Hall 1, Space -1, Cao -1, Salazar -1, Scott Murphy -2, Perriello -2, Foster -5
ROUND 12 RESULTS: Maffei 10, Djou 9, Kirkpatrick 8, Grayson 6, Schauer 3, Wilson 3, Salazar -1, Space -1, Cao -2, Perriello -2, Hall -4, Foster -4
ROUND 13 RESULTS: Wilson 14, Kirkpatrick 11, Schauer 4, Carney 3, Cao -1, Foster -2, Inglis -3, Grayson -6
ROUND 14 RESULTS: Schauer 18, Carney 7, Dahlkemper 4, Grayson 3, Hall 2, Inglis -2, Foster -3, Cao -4
ROUND 15 RESULTS: Dahlkemper 16, Mitchell 4 (4 eliminate points this round, no points in previous rounds), Hall 4 (4 eliminate points this round, -4 points in previous rounds), Patrick Murphy 3, Foster 0, Inglis -1, Grayson -1, Cao -2, Scott Murphy -3
ROUND 16 RESULTS: Hall 15, Salazar 6, Patrick Murphy 5, Scott Murphy 4, Space 4, Kagen 2, Inglis -2, Cao -2, Grayson -12
ROUND 17 RESULTS: Driehaus 10, Patrick Murphy 9, Scott Murphy 7, Kagen 5, Foster 3, Cao -1, Inglis -2, Space -2, Grayson -9
ROUND 18 RESULTS: Kagen 12, Grayson 11, Cao 6, Scott Murphy 5, Patrick Murphy 5, Inglis -2, Space -2, Perriello -5
ROUND 19 RESULTS: Scott Murphy 15, Patrick Murphy 10, Inglis 4, Grayson 4, Cao 2, Pomeroy -2, Rodriguez -3
ROUND 20 RESULTS: Shea-Porter 17, Cao 10, Patrick Murphy 8, Space 2, Inglis 0, Pomeroy -2, Grayson -5
ROUND 21 RESULTS: Patrick Murphy 14, Inglis 12, Cao 8, Hill 1, Grayson -5

POINTS IN PREVIOUS ROUNDS: Inglis 4, Hill 1, Pomeroy -4, Space -7, Rodriguez -8, Foster -10, Perriello -14, Cao -14, Grayson -18

Round 22 is open, and will close no earlier than 3:00 PM Eastern Time on Friday, February 4th. Remember that you have ten “eliminate” points, divided as you choose among ANY NUMBER of defeated incumbents, and five “keep” points, divided as you choose among any number of defeated incumbents. The one with the most points will be eliminated.

[homelycooking]

Eliminate

8 Baron Hill
2 Chet Edwards

Keep

5 Alan Grayson

[Nhoj]

Eliminate
10  Grayson


Keep

5 Bob Inglis

[big bad fab]

Eliminate
10 Baron Hill

Keep
3 Joseph Cao
2 Bob Inglis

[Niemeyerite]

eliminate 10 Cao
keep 5 baron hill

[Edu]

10 for Baron Hill

Keep
5 for Alan Grayson

[minionofmidas]

10 to off Inglis, 5 to keep Cao

[big bad fab]

Wouldn't Foster be a good idea for next round ?

[Niemeyerite]

Wouldn't Foster be a good idea for next round ?

Edwards would be a better idea =)

[Vazdul (Formerly Chairman of the Communist Party of Ontario)]

Hill 23
Inglis 3
Cao 2
Edwards 2
Grayson 0

THE TOP 15:

Joseph Cao (R, LA-2)
Steve Driehaus (D, OH-1) ELIMINATED ROUND 17
Chet Edwards (D, TX-17)
Bill Foster (D, IL-14)
Alan Grayson (D, FL-8)
Baron Hill (D, IN-9) ELIMINATED ROUND 22
Bob Inglis (R, SC-4)
Steven Kagen (D, WI-8) ELIMINATED ROUND 18
Patrick Murphy (D, PA-8) ELIMINATED ROUND 21
Scott Murphy (D, NY-20) ELIMINATED ROUND 19
Tom Perriello (D, VA-5)
Earl Pomeroy (D, ND-AL)
Ciro Rodriguez (D, TX-23)
Carol Shea-Porter (D, NH-1) ELIMINATED ROUND 20
Zack Space (D, OH-18)

ROUND 1 RESULTS: Griffith 12, Kilpatrick 8, Taylor 5, Oberstar 2, Hare 1, Bright 1, Skelton 1, Kanjorski 0, Sandlin -1, Minnick -3, Cao -3, Shea-Porter -4
ROUND 2 RESULTS: Mollohan 8, Hare 6, Skelton 5, Ortiz 4, Marshall 2, Boucher 2, Oberstar 2, Bright -1, Sandlin -1, Kanjorski -1, Cao -3, Minnick -3
ROUND 3 RESULTS: Ortiz 9, Oberstar 8, Kanjorski 8, Bright 7, Halvorson 5, Kosmas 2, Marshall 2, Davis 2, Etheridge 1, Grayson 1, Hall -1, Shea-Porter -1, Scott Murphy -1, Perriello -1, Boucher -2, Rodriguez -3, Sandlin -3, Cao -3
ROUND 4 RESULTS: Davis 11, Bright 9, Halvorson 8, Spratt 5, Marshall 4, Boucher 2, Kosmas 2, Etheridge -1, Sandlin -1, Bean -2, Grayson -3, Teague -4, Cao -5
ROUND 5 RESULTS: Spratt 9, Marshall 6, Boucher 5, Bean 4, Kosmas 2, Kratovil 2, McMahon 2, Etheridge 1, Sandlin -1, Teague -1, Hall -2, Minnick -2
ROUND 6 RESULTS: McMahon 12, Nye 8, Kosmas 5 (6 eliminate points in the current round), Kratovil 5 (5 eliminate points in the current round), Childers 2, Sandlin 0, Cao 0, Teague 0, Minnick 0, Etheridge 0, Hall -1, Bean -2, Perriello -4
ROUND 7 RESULTS: Kratovil 13, Childers 6, Teague 5, Bean 3, Minnick 1, Etheridge 1, Rodriguez -2, Cao -3, Sandlin -4
ROUND 8 RESULTS: Minnick 8, Kilroy 8, Sandlin 6, Bean 5, Etheridge 2, Grayson 1, Djou 1, Foster 1, Cao -1, Boccieri -1, Space -4
ROUND 9 RESULTS: Bean 10, Boyd 6, Etheridge 4, Foster 3, Klein 2, Adler 2, Boccieri 1, Djou -1, Cao -7
ROUND 10 RESULTS: Adler 9, Titus 4, Arcuri 4, Boccieri 3, Markey 3, Klein 2, Maffei 2, Hall 1, Scott Murphy 1, Salazar -1, Cao -2, Carney -2, Foster -3, Space -3, Grayson -3
ROUND 11 RESULTS: Markey 7, Boccieri 7, Klein 6, Wilson 4, Maffei 2, Hall 1, Space -1, Cao -1, Salazar -1, Scott Murphy -2, Perriello -2, Foster -5
ROUND 12 RESULTS: Maffei 10, Djou 9, Kirkpatrick 8, Grayson 6, Schauer 3, Wilson 3, Salazar -1, Space -1, Cao -2, Perriello -2, Hall -4, Foster -4
ROUND 13 RESULTS: Wilson 14, Kirkpatrick 11, Schauer 4, Carney 3, Cao -1, Foster -2, Inglis -3, Grayson -6
ROUND 14 RESULTS: Schauer 18, Carney 7, Dahlkemper 4, Grayson 3, Hall 2, Inglis -2, Foster -3, Cao -4
ROUND 15 RESULTS: Dahlkemper 16, Mitchell 4 (4 eliminate points this round, no points in previous rounds), Hall 4 (4 eliminate points this round, -4 points in previous rounds), Patrick Murphy 3, Foster 0, Inglis -1, Grayson -1, Cao -2, Scott Murphy -3
ROUND 16 RESULTS: Hall 15, Salazar 6, Patrick Murphy 5, Scott Murphy 4, Space 4, Kagen 2, Inglis -2, Cao -2, Grayson -12
ROUND 17 RESULTS: Driehaus 10, Patrick Murphy 9, Scott Murphy 7, Kagen 5, Foster 3, Cao -1, Inglis -2, Space -2, Grayson -9
ROUND 18 RESULTS: Kagen 12, Grayson 11, Cao 6, Scott Murphy 5, Patrick Murphy 5, Inglis -2, Space -2, Perriello -5
ROUND 19 RESULTS: Scott Murphy 15, Patrick Murphy 10, Inglis 4, Grayson 4, Cao 2, Pomeroy -2, Rodriguez -3
ROUND 20 RESULTS: Shea-Porter 17, Cao 10, Patrick Murphy 8, Space 2, Inglis 0, Pomeroy -2, Grayson -5
ROUND 21 RESULTS: Patrick Murphy 14, Inglis 12, Cao 8, Hill 1, Grayson -5
ROUND 22 RESULTS: Hill 23, Inglis 3, Cao 2, Edwards 2, Grayson 0

POINTS IN PREVIOUS ROUNDS: Inglis 7, Edwards 2, Pomeroy -4, Space -7, Rodriguez -8, Foster -10, Perriello -14, Cao -12, Grayson -18

Round 23 is open, and will close no earlier than 7:15 PM Eastern Time on Sunday, February 6th. Remember that you have ten “eliminate” points, divided as you choose among ANY NUMBER of defeated incumbents, and five “keep” points, divided as you choose among any number of defeated incumbents. The one with the most points will be eliminated.

[homelycooking]

Eliminate

7 Chet Edwards
3 Bill Foster

Keep

5 Alan Grayson

[minionofmidas]

Eliminate 10 Inglis, dammit.
Keep 3 Cao, 2 Foster

[big bad fab]

Eliminate
9 Foster
1 Grayson

Keep
1 Cao
2 Edwards
2 Inglis

[Niemeyerite]

eliminate 10 chet edwards

keep 5 bill foster

[Nhoj]

eliminate
10 Zack Space

keep 5 bill foster

[Edu]

So, because Fab for some reason gave 1 vote for Grayson (which considering he has -18 in previous rounds, was pretty useless ), i probably won't be able to oust Foster this round like i wanted

Eliminate
10 for Bill Foster

Keep
5 for Chet Edwards

[Vazdul (Formerly Chairman of the Communist Party of Ontario)]

Apparently Edu has forgotten that the first tiebreaker is number of eliminate points in the current round. Foster has 22, compared to 17 for Edwards and 10 for Space, so Foster is out.



Foster 10 (22 eliminate points in current round)
Edwards 10 (17 eliminate points in current round)
Space 10 (10 eliminate points in current round)
Inglis 8
Cao -4
Grayson -4

THE TOP 15:

Joseph Cao (R, LA-2)
Steve Driehaus (D, OH-1) ELIMINATED ROUND 17
Chet Edwards (D, TX-17)
Bill Foster (D, IL-14) ELIMINATED ROUND 23
Alan Grayson (D, FL-8)
Baron Hill (D, IN-9) ELIMINATED ROUND 22
Bob Inglis (R, SC-4)
Steven Kagen (D, WI-8) ELIMINATED ROUND 18
Patrick Murphy (D, PA-8) ELIMINATED ROUND 21
Scott Murphy (D, NY-20) ELIMINATED ROUND 19
Tom Perriello (D, VA-5)
Earl Pomeroy (D, ND-AL)
Ciro Rodriguez (D, TX-23)
Carol Shea-Porter (D, NH-1) ELIMINATED ROUND 20
Zack Space (D, OH-18)

ROUND 1 RESULTS: Griffith 12, Kilpatrick 8, Taylor 5, Oberstar 2, Hare 1, Bright 1, Skelton 1, Kanjorski 0, Sandlin -1, Minnick -3, Cao -3, Shea-Porter -4
ROUND 2 RESULTS: Mollohan 8, Hare 6, Skelton 5, Ortiz 4, Marshall 2, Boucher 2, Oberstar 2, Bright -1, Sandlin -1, Kanjorski -1, Cao -3, Minnick -3
ROUND 3 RESULTS: Ortiz 9, Oberstar 8, Kanjorski 8, Bright 7, Halvorson 5, Kosmas 2, Marshall 2, Davis 2, Etheridge 1, Grayson 1, Hall -1, Shea-Porter -1, Scott Murphy -1, Perriello -1, Boucher -2, Rodriguez -3, Sandlin -3, Cao -3
ROUND 4 RESULTS: Davis 11, Bright 9, Halvorson 8, Spratt 5, Marshall 4, Boucher 2, Kosmas 2, Etheridge -1, Sandlin -1, Bean -2, Grayson -3, Teague -4, Cao -5
ROUND 5 RESULTS: Spratt 9, Marshall 6, Boucher 5, Bean 4, Kosmas 2, Kratovil 2, McMahon 2, Etheridge 1, Sandlin -1, Teague -1, Hall -2, Minnick -2
ROUND 6 RESULTS: McMahon 12, Nye 8, Kosmas 5 (6 eliminate points in the current round), Kratovil 5 (5 eliminate points in the current round), Childers 2, Sandlin 0, Cao 0, Teague 0, Minnick 0, Etheridge 0, Hall -1, Bean -2, Perriello -4
ROUND 7 RESULTS: Kratovil 13, Childers 6, Teague 5, Bean 3, Minnick 1, Etheridge 1, Rodriguez -2, Cao -3, Sandlin -4
ROUND 8 RESULTS: Minnick 8, Kilroy 8, Sandlin 6, Bean 5, Etheridge 2, Grayson 1, Djou 1, Foster 1, Cao -1, Boccieri -1, Space -4
ROUND 9 RESULTS: Bean 10, Boyd 6, Etheridge 4, Foster 3, Klein 2, Adler 2, Boccieri 1, Djou -1, Cao -7
ROUND 10 RESULTS: Adler 9, Titus 4, Arcuri 4, Boccieri 3, Markey 3, Klein 2, Maffei 2, Hall 1, Scott Murphy 1, Salazar -1, Cao -2, Carney -2, Foster -3, Space -3, Grayson -3
ROUND 11 RESULTS: Markey 7, Boccieri 7, Klein 6, Wilson 4, Maffei 2, Hall 1, Space -1, Cao -1, Salazar -1, Scott Murphy -2, Perriello -2, Foster -5
ROUND 12 RESULTS: Maffei 10, Djou 9, Kirkpatrick 8, Grayson 6, Schauer 3, Wilson 3, Salazar -1, Space -1, Cao -2, Perriello -2, Hall -4, Foster -4
ROUND 13 RESULTS: Wilson 14, Kirkpatrick 11, Schauer 4, Carney 3, Cao -1, Foster -2, Inglis -3, Grayson -6
ROUND 14 RESULTS: Schauer 18, Carney 7, Dahlkemper 4, Grayson 3, Hall 2, Inglis -2, Foster -3, Cao -4
ROUND 15 RESULTS: Dahlkemper 16, Mitchell 4 (4 eliminate points this round, no points in previous rounds), Hall 4 (4 eliminate points this round, -4 points in previous rounds), Patrick Murphy 3, Foster 0, Inglis -1, Grayson -1, Cao -2, Scott Murphy -3
ROUND 16 RESULTS: Hall 15, Salazar 6, Patrick Murphy 5, Scott Murphy 4, Space 4, Kagen 2, Inglis -2, Cao -2, Grayson -12
ROUND 17 RESULTS: Driehaus 10, Patrick Murphy 9, Scott Murphy 7, Kagen 5, Foster 3, Cao -1, Inglis -2, Space -2, Grayson -9
ROUND 18 RESULTS: Kagen 12, Grayson 11, Cao 6, Scott Murphy 5, Patrick Murphy 5, Inglis -2, Space -2, Perriello -5
ROUND 19 RESULTS: Scott Murphy 15, Patrick Murphy 10, Inglis 4, Grayson 4, Cao 2, Pomeroy -2, Rodriguez -3
ROUND 20 RESULTS: Shea-Porter 17, Cao 10, Patrick Murphy 8, Space 2, Inglis 0, Pomeroy -2, Grayson -5
ROUND 21 RESULTS: Patrick Murphy 14, Inglis 12, Cao 8, Hill 1, Grayson -5
ROUND 22 RESULTS: Hill 23, Inglis 3, Cao 2, Edwards 2, Grayson 0
ROUND 23 RESULTS: Foster 10 (22 eliminate points this round), Edwards 10 (17 eliminate points this round), Space 10 (10 eliminate points this round), Inglis 8, Cao -4, Grayson -4

POINTS IN PREVIOUS ROUNDS: Inglis 15, Edwards 12, Space 3, Pomeroy -4, Rodriguez -8, Perriello -14, Cao -16, Grayson -22

Round 24 is open, and will close no earlier than 12:00 AM Eastern Time on Tuesday, February 8th. Remember that you have ten “eliminate” points, divided as you choose among ANY NUMBER of defeated incumbents, and five “keep” points, divided as you choose among any number of defeated incumbents. The one with the most points will be eliminated.

[big bad fab]

Sorry Edu for having worried you a bit.
Fortunately, it ends well.

I don't know what to do anymore. Trying to save Edwards, Space, Inglis, Cao, Pomeroy and Grayson at the same time is too much. That's why I drop more or less Grayson...

Eliminate
8 Ciro Rodriguez
2 Alan Grayson

Keep
2 Cao
2 Space
1 Inglis

[homelycooking]

Eliminate

8 Chet Edwards
2 Ciro Rodriguez

Keep

5 Alan Grayson

[Nhoj]

Eliminate

8 Alan Grayson

2 Ciro Rodriguez

Keep

5 Bob Inglis

[Niemeyerite]

eliminate 10 chet edwards

keep 5 ciro rodriguez

[Edu]

Yeah, i forgot the elimination rules, glad i was wrong

Eliminate
10 for Ciro Rodriguez

Keep
3 for Alan Grayson
2 for Chet Edwards

[minionofmidas]

keep Ciro 5

eliminate anyone who dared vote to eliminate Ciro Edwards 9, Inglis 1