Opinion of this redistricting proposal?

[Cincinnatus]

Not in favor.  As I've said in the other thread, this proposal would make these regions less competitive because it would leave us with one liberal region, one conservative region, and one competitive region.  And while I love to see Northeast have the influence it does in these elections, I don't believe it would be fair.  The boundaries should be kept the same, but the South needs to have better legislators, is all.

How is this any different than what we have now?  We currently have 4 uncompetitive regions, with one competitive one. 

[Cincinnatus]

Lets see, 3 Regional Senate seats, 5 At-Large. Nope, no imbalance against the regions there.

We could do two senate seats from each regional. With five at large we would then have 11 senators. I suppose we could just get rid of the Vice-Presidency then as well.

Or simply make the Vice President a Senator as well...

Though, 12 Senators is quite a bit.  In fact, I find 10 to be quite a bit already.

[Cincinnatus]

The Northeast will never relinquish PA to the Southeast.  That is all

[Cincinnatus]

Hmm this thread has certainly gotten more response when I basically proposed the same thing a month or two ago.

Because you proposed it, obviously.  Though I do believe I responded in agreement with your proposal