Just out of curiosity Nathan, have you ever seen anyone with any of these at church? None strike me as very New England WASP, even in Amherst:
-Plugs/gauges
-Hipster scarves
-Piercings anywhere than the ears
-Band shirt
-Hoodie
-Tattoos over an entire arm
-Large chestpiece or back tattoos.
-Lower back tattoo ("Tramp stamp")
I once knew a Christian hardcore girl with a Bible verse for the last one.
When I go with my family you would see me arrive in a jacket and tie and my son in a band shirt or hoodie. Nothing wrong with that from my perspective.
