The PA voter ID law is certainly more restrictive than Canada's. PA appears to only have one of the three prongs Canada uses to verify, and that is a government-issued photo id. Canada allows for two non-photo options as well.
It is actually easier to get welfare benefits in PA that it is to vote, at least in terms of ID and residency.
There is a need for verification of voter's ID, but this law is too draconian.
It would seem more natural to make a uniform standard for ID whether for voting or state benefits.
Easily so.
Consider this. I've voted in the same polling station for 13 years. People there know me, and I them. There is a record of my signature there. I will have to show ID this time.
If I lose my driver's license, I cannot vote, in spite of the fact that I have two signed credit cards, a signed lease and numerous utility bills in my name, a signed bank card, a signed voter registration card, a signed library card, and signed verification of my IQ range.