Assessing the need for Black VRA districts in Florida

[Sbane]

One district can easily be drawn that is likely to reflect Black voters preferences and that is in the north Miami area. But are the other two districts, the Jacksonville to Orlando district in the north and the Fort Lauderdale/Palm Beach district in the south, necessary. So if someone draws a truly fair map of Florida, would they need to draw those districts to be compliant? I know there aren't any clear cut answers here but I would like to know what you all think are the chances of a lawsuit if those districts aren't drawn and what the likely outcome would be.

[Sbane]

Isn't this decision saying that the 3rd and 23rd were ok to draw in 2000 (when presumably the Black population was higher?). It doesn't say anything about not drawing these districts and in their place drawing compact districts that made a reasonable effort to not split the black vote. So a district wholly within Broward county which takes in all of the city of Fort Lauderdale and the black areas right next to it but doesn't go into Palm Beach county. The 3rd district seems completely ridiculous to me but it's the 23rd I am not sure about.