Make a map of the above four posters as separate candidates

[Antonio the Sixth]

A Person (D): 35.7%, 258 EV
Matt (R): 37.4%, 208 EV
Spendstar (G): 16.1%, 37 EV
Vosem (L): 10.8%, 35 EV

A Person and Spendstar make a deal in the Electoral College, so that the election doesn't go to the House.

[JerryArkansas]

Matt 42
Vosem 366
Californian Tony 99
a Person 31

[Blackacre]

Matt 42
Vosem 366
Californian Tony 99
a Person 31

why is maine a tossup?

[JerryArkansas]

would not allow me to make it yellow, so I made it tossup

[Antonio the Sixth]

How in the flying hell would Matt carry New England?

[Sopranos Republican]

How in the flying hell would Matt carry New England?

I think I would have a good shot at New Hampshire and possibly Vermont since I'm from here and I'm facing two liberals (of course that's assuming not many vote for Vosem) No shot at Mass or Rhode Island, CT and Maine could be competitive because of the liberal vote being split.

Jerry wins in a landslide due to the liberal vote being split into 3.
jerryarkansas 327 Electoral votes
Antonio V 148 Electoral Votes
Spenstar 3D 44 Electoral votes
a person 19 electoral votes

[The world will shine with light in our nightmare]

Antonio V/Jerry Brown - 169 EVs
Jerryarkansas/Joe Manchin - 126 EVs
Averroës Nix/Brian Schweitzer - 125 EVs
Matt/Rand Paul - 118 EVs

[Goldwater]

Vote Splitting on the left leads to a landslide victory for Matt.

Governor Matt (R-VT) - 363 EVs
Governor Scott (D-CT) - 91 EVs
Senator Averroës Nix (I-NY) - 29 EVs
Senator Antonio "Tony" V (S-CA) - 55 EVs

[JerryArkansas]

Goldwater 136
Scott 58
Matt 157
Nix 187

[TNF]

Gov. Jerry of Arkansas and Sen. Bob Corker of Tennessee (Republican)
Former Lt. Gov. Goldwater of Washington and Kristin Davis of New York (Libertarian/Anti-Prohibition)
Gov. Scott of Connecticut and Former Governor Phil Bredesen of Tennessee (Democratic)
Sen. Nix of New York and Congresswoman Loretta Sanchez of California (Independence)

The Democratic Party splits in the primary campaign between Senator Nix of New York and Governor Scott of Connecticut. Scott, however, manages to rally the left to his side and wins the nomination, but Nix announces his own bid as an independent.

On the Republican side, Governor Jerry wins the nomination pretty easily. Former Washington Lt. Governor and former Republican Goldwater wins the libertarian and anti-prohibition nominations and runs to Jerry's right, picking up some dissatisfied with the Governor's moderation on fiscal and social policy matters.

Ultimately Jerry wins 377-160-1 with only 41% of the vote.

[Supersonic]

Governor Jerry Arkansas (Republican-AR) - 242 EVs
Governor Scott (Democrat-CT) - 273 EVs
Fmr. Senator Goldwater (Libertarian-WA) - 9 EVs
Congressman TNF (Populist-KY) - 14 EVs

- The Democrats win as Scott holds his base with greater succcess than Jerry who loses Libertarian and younger Republicans to Goldwater while TNF damages the traditionally GOP white working class. Nevertheless the election is still fairly close. -

[Goldwater]

Bump.

[The world will shine with light in our nightmare]

A three-way split in the conservative vote leads to a landslide victory for TNF.

TNF (Democratic) - 486 Electoral Votes
Goldwater (Republican) - 13 Electoral Votes
Supersonic (Conservative) - 35 Electoral Votes
JerryArkansas (Independent) - 4 Electoral Votes

[Enderman]

Goldwater 271 EVS
Scott 173 EVS
TNF 76 EVS
S. S. Venue 18 EVS

The split vote in for Democrats, and a double attack by Conservatives against the Democrats, easily gave the election to Rand Paulesque Conservatarian Goldwater...

[Goldwater]

Senator Scott (D-CT) - 247 EVs
Governor Supersonic (R-TN) - 192 EVs
Governor Jack Enderman (L-FL) - 52 EVs
Senator TNF (S-KY) - 47 EVs

The election goes to the House, where Supersonic is elected president.

[TNF]

Centrist Democrats, upset with the path that President Nix (D-NY) has charted in his first term, funnel money and support behind an insurgent candidacy by former Senator Scott of Connecticut, a centrist 'New Democrat' that manages to overwhelm and defeat the incumbent President at the Democratic convention in Nashville. Decrying his denial of renomination a plot by 'big business, polluters, and the political right', Nix makes it known that he will seek the nomination of the Green Party for the White House, a nomination he easily wins owing to his very 'green' record in the White House. In addition, Nix begins removing key Democratic operatives from his cabinet who don't support the administration, issues an executive order banning fracking, and goes after the tax incentives for gas and oil companies.

On the Republican side, Washington Governor Goldwater wins the nomination easily without much of a contest. A controversial former sheriff of a small Florida town, Jack Enderman, wins the Libertarian nomination for President and runs a quixotic campaign that quickly becomes an internet sensation.

Former Senator Scott (D-CT) / Phil Bredesen (D-TN) - 12 (23.2% of the PV)
President Averroes Nix (G-NY) / Vice President Bruce Braley (D-IA) - 124 (36% of the PV)
Governor Goldwater (R-WA) / Governor John Kasich (R-OH) - 402 (39.8% of the PV)
Jack Enderman (Lib-FL) / Jimmy McMillan (Lib-NY) - 0 (1% of the PV)

In the end, the split on the left helps Goldwater defeat Nix and Scott both. The Republicans hold the House (but the Greens pick up a record number of seats), gain the Senate (again, the Greens pick up seats here), and give Goldwater a free hand in enacting his agenda. His first executive order rescinds Nix's ban on fracking and with the help of House Speaker Supersonic (R-TN), he begins dismantling recently enacted Nixian legislation.

[Pessimistic Antineutrino]

President Averroes Nix (D-NY) - 242 EVs (31.9% of the PV)
Governor Goldwater (R-WA) - 231 EVs (33.2% of the PV)
Senator TNF (I-KY) - 55 EVs (22.5% of the PV)
Former Rep. Jack Enderman (L-FL) - 10 EVs (12.4% of the PV)

Excessive vote splitting from both the right and left causes a major split in the PV, with no candidate getting over a third of the vote. The election goes to the house. Former Representative Jack Enderman does not qualify for the house vote, due to placing fourth, and so withdraws from the race. After no majorities on the first and second house ballots, Senator TNF withdraws and endorses President Nix, but several key delegations tip towards Goldwater, giving him the presidency.

Governor Goldwater (R-WA) - 22
President Averroes Nix (D-NY) -12
Senator TNF (I-KY) - 10
Abstain/No Vote - 6

Nix and TNF manage to clinch several delegations from Republican-majority states, such as Pennsylvania and North Carolina.

Governor Goldwater (R-WA) - 24
President Averroes Nix (D-NY) -11
Senator TNF (I-KY) - 11
Abstain/No Vote - 4

Goldwater picks off the North Carolina delegation from Nix, as well as the deadlocked Ohio delegation. TNF picks up the deadlocked Maine delegation.

Governor Goldwater (R-WA) - 28
President Averroes Nix (D-NY) - 19
Abstain/No Vote - 3

Despite Nix maintaining crossover support from several delegations, the withdrawal of TNF flips several states to Goldwater, pulling him over the crucial 26 vote line into the White House.

[Antonio the Sixth]

TNF: 29%, 163 EV
Averroes: 31%, 161 EV
Goldwater: 24%, 116 EV
Antineutrino: 16%, 98 EV

The House picks Goldwater.

[Goldwater]

Vote splitting on the left leads to a comfortable victory for Antineutrino.

Governor Antineutrino (R-NJ) - 295 EVs
Senator Antonio (D-CA) - 105 EVs
Mayor Nix (I-NY) - 72 EVs
Senator TNF (Populist-KY) - 66 EVs

[Oldiesfreak1854]

Sen. Tony (Democratic-CA)/Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand (Democratic-NY): 235
Gov. Antineutrion (Republican-NJ)/Sen. John Thune (Republican-SD): 154
Gov. Goldwater (Libertarian-WA)/Sen. Rand Paul (Libertarian-KY): 136
Sen. TNF (Populist-KY)/Sen. Joe Manchin (Populist-WV): 15

House Vote

Gov. Antineutrino (Republican-NJ): 30
Sen.Tony (Democratic-CA): 17
No Vote: 3

[CatoMinor]

As the primaries were rapping up, the GOP began having huge sigh of relief. The moderate hero candidate Senator Olie S. Freake of Michigan had won the nomination and the Democrats had nominated Senator Antonio of New Jersey who was considered my most to be too radical. The libertarians had nominated former GOP representative Goldwater of Washington. Running as an independent conservative, was the Governor of New Jersey "Pessy" Antineutrino. Early polls showed Sen. Freake with a decent lead, however it began to diminish greatly as audio clips were leaked of offensive remarks made about southerners and conservatives. Soon the media began to dub it "Dixiegate" and within weeks Antonio and Freake were tied at 35% each and the rest undecided or leaning 3rd party. The bottom dropping out from Sen. Freake's campaign greatly aided Governor Pessy as his poll numbers shot up to 16%, enough to make the debate a 3-way for the first time since 1992. The 3 debates were an unmitigated disaster for Sen. Freake who quickly fell into making cheap shots at conservatism, and ranting on how the south was ruing this country, worst yet came when he denounced all Democrats as racists and the party of slavery, effectively ending all cross over support.
After the debates the GOP national commitee decided to begin cutting connections to Olie and unofficially began to support Pessy. The State GOP leadership of at least 15 states outright endorsed Pessy in an act of rebellion. By election day, Freake had dropped to under 20% and was expected to carry only Michigan, as it was the only state where Pessy had not made the ballot. It turned out that Goldwater would  be able to win just enough to throw Michigan to Antonio.

Governor "Plessy" Antineutrino - 41%
Senator Antonio - 34%
Fmr. Rep Goldwater - 15%
Senator Olie S. Freake - 10%

[TNF]

1860.

Senator Antonio (R-Calif.): 183
Governor Oldiesfreak (Constitutional Union-Tennessee): 59
Senator Jbrase (Southern Democrat-Texas): 55
Governor Goldwater (D-Delaware): 6

[Antonio the Sixth]

TNF: 44.6%, 362 EV
JBrase: 25.1%, 131 EV
Goldwater: 19.5%, 28 EV
Oldies: 10.8%, 141

[Enderman]

I think I had a dream about this once...

Senator Jay Brase R-IA/Senator Kelly Ayotte R-NH 275 EVS
Governor Tony Calif D-CA/Governor Martin O'Malley D-MD 201 EVS
Representative Ollie S Freake R/L-MI/Senator John Thune R-SD 38 EVS
Senator Tee N'uff D/I-KY/Senator Joe Lieberman I-CT 24 EVS

[Maxwell]

Antonio California campaigned as a Liberal in 2008, but by 2012 many liberals found him a bit too pragmatic for their tastes. Governor TNF, a staunch liberal and pro-labor man, gained traction running against Antonio on trade issues and labor unions. Meanwhile, little known congressman from Florida Jack Enderman managed to speed past his more well known competitors Mitt Romney and Mike Huckabee by staying positive and strategically aiming at early states. His delegate strategy worked and he picked Pat Toomey, an Senator that doubled down on the new faces campaign. Enderman looked toast when a scandal arose on TNF, but Enderman still prevailed due to strong liberal support for TNF, and conservative turnout for the young congressman.

Congressman Jack Enderman (Rep-FL)/Senator Pat Toomey (R-PA) - 39.8%, 311 EV's
President Antonio California (Dem-CA)/Vice President Andrew Cuomo (D-NY) - 34.7%, 199 EV's
Governor TNF (Soc-KY)/Senator Bernie Sanders (Soc-VT) - 18.2%, 28 EV's
Congressman James Brase (Lib-TX)/Congressman Walter Jones (Lib-NC) - 6.8%, 0 EV's
Others - 0.5%, 0 EV's