Hitler or Stalin: Who Was Worse

[Gustaf]

Geez, they both really suck! This is like "which is worse, pancreatic cancer or a non-operable brain tumor?"

Hm, that's a good question. I would say pancreatic cancer, since having something in my brain would really freak me out...

[Siege40]

When I think about it, had Hitler won he would of killed roughly 20 million people in genocidal methods, Stalin through his reign did kill 30 million, if not more. Based on numbers Stalin was worst, that does not include war death or occupation deaths. I know Stalin wasted more lives in the war, but Germany was a harsher occupier. Regardless, captured soldiers on either side didn't last long.

Siege

[Gustaf]

When I think about it, had Hitler won he would of killed roughly 20 million people in genocidal methods, Stalin through his reign did kill 30 million, if not more. Based on numbers Stalin was worst, that does not include war death or occupation deaths. I know Stalin wasted more lives in the war, but Germany was a harsher occupier. Regardless, captured soldiers on either side didn't last long.

Siege

In fact, Russian soldiers didn't last lon in their Russian captivity...

[Siege40]

When I think about it, had Hitler won he would of killed roughly 20 million people in genocidal methods, Stalin through his reign did kill 30 million, if not more. Based on numbers Stalin was worst, that does not include war death or occupation deaths. I know Stalin wasted more lives in the war, but Germany was a harsher occupier. Regardless, captured soldiers on either side didn't last long.

Siege

In fact, Russian soldiers didn't last lon in their Russian captivity...

Velcome to ze Gulag...

[Gustaf]

When I think about it, had Hitler won he would of killed roughly 20 million people in genocidal methods, Stalin through his reign did kill 30 million, if not more. Based on numbers Stalin was worst, that does not include war death or occupation deaths. I know Stalin wasted more lives in the war, but Germany was a harsher occupier. Regardless, captured soldiers on either side didn't last long.

Siege

In fact, Russian soldiers didn't last lon in their Russian captivity...

Velcome to ze Gulag...

Yeah, they sent most of the Russian soldiers who had seen the wonders of the bombed Germany to Siberia, so they wouldn't spread the word...

[??????????]

Fact is more Russian soldiers came out of German camps then Germans who went into Russian camps

[Gustaf]

Fact is more Russian soldiers came out of German camps then Germans who went into Russian camps

So...? One side lost the other won...and are you talking relative or absolute numbers here?

[??????????]

If the war is over wouldn't have been the law for the Russians to have released German POWs? Stalins actions after the second world war in regards to the eastern european states were very disturbing to say the least.

[Gustaf]

If the war is over wouldn't have been the law for the Russians to have released German POWs? Stalins actions after the second world war in regards to the eastern european states were very disturbing to say the least.

Yes...but that's not my point. If Hitler had won he wouldn't have released his Russian  prisoners.

[Brambila]

Dunn, can you imagine if Hitler was there 20 years earlier? The fact is he wasn't. Hitler for his period of time did a lot of damage- 6 million Jews, and 11 million slavs in about 10 years, but Stalin was on a similar role.