I had a hard time deciding on any candidates from the 1860's until the 1960's as mostly all of the candidates were progressive/leftist/communists. It's not much better now, though. Republicans aren't conservative & Democrats are socialists.
So of course you chose parties with totally opposite views of yours... Actually in the 1860s, the Democrats would've fit you well...
However, given your votes for total nutjobs like Schmitz and neo-nazis like Gerald Lyman Kenneth Smith, I take that most parties are not extreme enough for you. Perhaps instead of Goldwater in 64, you should've wrote in Lincoln Rockwell... If you don't know who he is, look him up.