These numbers are kind of interesting. I think this is probably a reasonable ceiling for someone whose beliefs piss off a lot of Atlas users but who is otherwise respectful and articulate.
If Fuzzy were more like an average Republican user in posting style, his FF numbers would probably crater.
Respectful?? It is the ultimate of disrespect (and well outside the mainstream, so nobody start) to believe our Jewish, Catholic, Mormon, and nonreligious posters will spend eternity burning in Hell.
Respectful in conversations with people is not the same as their beliefs themselves. Someone can have horrible ideas but still convey them nicely. It doesn't change who they are and what their beliefs make them, it just means they communicate it respectfully. I don't see anything wrong with making this distinction.