Tweed: 1964 had Goldwater man! Sure LBJ was as bad as you can get, but Goldwater was the man...
1840, 1856, 1868, 1988, 2004 were the worst 5 with 1856 being dead last.
Bush Sr. was TONS better than Bush Jr., and Dukakis was probably on par with Kerry.
What was so horrid about Van Buren and Harrison compared to Bush and Kerry?
I see what you mean with 1856 and 1868 though. Though I'd probably put 1872 after 1868, since no one had any idea how bad Grant would be in '68, but he had proven himself as a bad president by '72.