Clinton/Obama: 365
Romney/Giuliani: 173
Brownback/Dobson: 0
Just a hypothetical about a third party Religious Right ticket. Brownback/Dobson is just a generic Religious Right ticket; I'm not expecting either of them to actually form into a third party, but I needed recognizable names.
I figure if it did happen the Republican Party would be in serious crisis and suffering from more problems than just a split with the Religious Right. It's an easy Democratic victory with the third party splitting the vote in the South allowing the Dems to pickup VA and AR.